SPINOZISTIC GLOSSARY
AND INDEX
Dedicated to Spinoza's
Insights
Introduction—Purpose
- Spinozistic Ideas
- Mark Twain and Spinoza
Graetz's Censure
of Spinoza - Durant's Tribute
JBY Web Pages -
Spinoza Electronic Texts - MIniCD
of Entire Site
Bibliography and Citation Abbreviations
- Topics & Threads
Spinozistic
Contributions to Wikipedia
Browser Notes—Use
800 x 600 resolution and medium
size text for all Pages.
Links—Britannica
- Link and Endnote Search -
Kindly tell
me of any broken links.
| 1. | Dictionary definitions are edited entries {
JBY emendations } from WP Random-House "Webster's Electronic Dictionary" (RH) or Oxford University Press "Concise Electronic Dictionary" (OUP) [ Etymology from RH or OUP
] Ethics: Part III: Def. of the Emotions XX Explanation:178 "But my purpose
is to explain, not the meaning of
|
Spinoza's Religion
|
2. |
Fully CAPITALIZED words do not necessarily have their everyday meaning; they are precisely defined terms, much like letting x=y (where y is the cause by hypothesis). If I fatally deviate from these precise definitions, the logical structure collapses (D:2.12), Please call me to account at josephb@yesselman.com. This capitalization is a JBY convention; not Spinoza's. A degree sign (°) indicates that the term constantly varies in degree when it is a mode, but not when it is an attribute. Calculus:Fig.3, Calculus:4.4. The dictionary definitions do not stress such variations. Note 1, Calculus:Fig.1(a), Calculus:Fig.1(b), E1:XIII:54, E1:XV(40):58 °P symbolizes the
variation in degree of Perpetuation |
° FAITH faith D:1.26b D:2.10 Calculus:Fig.1 D:1.37 I:1.3b I:1.4b D:1.30 DefEmo Includes Quibble D:1.14 James |
| 3. | Symbols: { -- } Indicates a JBY comment or statement. [ -- ] Indicates a Curley's translation or comment. ] -- [ Indicates a Shirley's translation or comment. <--> Indicates a Parkinson's translation or comment. >--< Indicates a De Dijn's translation or comment. LINKS. |
Bk.XIB:22377. |
| 4. | Bibliography and Citation Abbreviations: Online Book-Ordering for Listed Books: Click Book or ISBN No. for an Amazon.com order form. Where available, click on book title to sample book. Booksellers: Abebooks, Albris. See this Interesting Canadian library source. I receive commissions on orders placed with Amazon. All commissions received are turned over to: North American Spinoza Society. Executive Secretary: Steven Barbone Conjecture: It
will be a happy day when all books are
On
the Improvement of the Understanding
(TEI): The Books I & II page numbers (when given)
for citations, afford the Book
II – Benedict de Spinoza A
Theologico-Political A Theologico-Political
Treatise (TTP) Part #: A
Political Treatise (TP) Part #: Elwes'
Introduction:[Para. # ]:Book II Page #
Book III: Page #, Footnote
or Endnote # This book is a valuable commentary on Spinoza's "Treatise on the Emendation of the Intellect" ( Book I ). It has the Gebhardt Latin text and Curley's English translation on facing pages. It describes in great detail Spinoza's Method
for acquiring Wisdom. |
|
| 4. Cont. |
Book
IV (7 Volumes) – The
Pentateuch; translated & explained (1873) by Rabbi Samsom Raphael Hirsch (1808-1888). Translated and Published by Isaac Levy. 237 Stoke Newington Church St. London N.16, England, Copyright 1959. Judaica Press, Brooklyn, NY. (718) 972-6000; ISBN 0910818126. Hirsch's non-conventional
translations and profound Hebrew
etymologically-based commentary
trigger insights. His rationalistic Hirsch Pentateuch: Biblical Book, Chapter: Verse |
|
| 4. Cont. |
Book V ( 2 Volumes) – The
Psalms translated & commentary (1882) by Rabbi Samsom Raphael Hirsch. Translated into English by Gertrude Hirschler. Copyright 1960 by Philipp Feldheim, Inc., New York, NY. Eichler's Book Store, Brooklyn, NY, (718)258-7643. See Book IV comments above. Volume 1 - Psalms 1 to 72. |
Psalm 1:1:1 |
| 4. Cont. |
Book
VI – H.W.F.
Gesenius's Hebrew-Chaldee Lexicon
to the {Hebrew Bible}; Baker
Books, 1997; ISDN: 0801037360. Numerically Coded to Strong's Exhaustive Concordance. Gesenius:Page Number Ges:19 The coding system allows the Bible student without a knowledge of Hebrew to use this classic work to find the precise meaning and connotations of the Hebrew or Aramaic word behind the English word being studied. Being a lexicon, its entries are more exhaustive than are Strong's. Study roots and related words of the 'word'–example the word 'pity' . |
|
| 4. Cont. |
Book
VII – "Baruch Spinoza; The
Ethics: Treatise on the Emendation of the Intellect and Selected Letters"; Translated by Samuel Shirley; Edited, with Introductions, by Seymour Feldman; Hackett Publishing Company,1992; ISBN: 0872201309. Get the hardcover; my paperback fell apart. Especially see Deus, Cause, Idea. Book VII: Page #, Footnote
or Endnote # |
|
| 4. Cont. |
Book
VIII (Volume 1) – The
Collected Works of Spinoza; Edited and Translated by Edwin Curley; 1985; Princeton University Press; (609)883-1759; ISBN: 0691072221. Available in a CD-ROM from IntLex's Past Master Series; The Continental Rationalists, Spinoza, Descartes, & Leibniz. I have added Curley's TEI Paragraph Numbers (which he took from Bruder; Book VIII, Page 6) to the Elwes translation. This I hope, will facilitate translation comparisons. If this is the same Bruder, strange Elwes did not use the Paragraph Numbers, unless Elwes' copy had no such numbers. Book VIII: Page #, Footnote
or Endnote #
Includes Dictionaries of Hebrew and Greek words (Strong
Numbers). Strong: Hebrew or Greek Word #
Book X: Page #, Footnote
or Endnote #
Book XI: Page #, Footnote
or Endnote #
Book XIA: Page #, Endnote
#
Book XIB: Page #, Endnote
#
Book XII: Page #, Footnote
or Endnote # |
|
| 4. Cont. |
Book
XIII – Spinoza:
The Letters; Translated
by Samuel Shirley; Introduction and Notes by Steven
Barbone, Lee Rice, and Jacob Adler. Hackett Publishing Company, Inc. Copyright 1995; ISBN: 0872202755. I recommend reading the Letters in Book XIII because of its Introduction and informative footnotes. Letter
# : Book XIII Page # , Footnote
or Endnote #
Book
XIV:Volume Number:Page #, Footnote
or Endnote # Book XV: Page #, Footnote
or Endnote #
Book XVI: Page #
Book XVII: Page #
Gebhardt's
Spinoza Opera (4 vols. 1925).
Book XIX: Page #, Endnote
# (Deleuse) or letter (Joughin).
Book XX: Page #, Endnote
#. See Nadler's entry in "Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy".
Book XXI: Page #, Endnote
#. Change Miller's definition of
God (Pg. 222) from
the traditional Judaic-Christian-Islam transcendent
God to Spinoza's immanent G-D and
the book could be titled "Finding Spinoza's G-D"
or even "Finding Einstein's
G-D", and possibly "Finding
Darwin's G-D".
The book is out-of-print; but may be obtained used here, where I got my copy. Search for Author "Runes".
Book XXVI: Page #, Endnote
#.
Book XXVII: Page #, Endnote
#.
Book XXVIII: Page #, Endnote
#.
LeDoux96:281—Is Consciousness Computable? Book XXIX: Page #, Endnote
#.
Book XXX: Page #, Endnote
#.
Book XXXI: Page #, Endnote
#. For online-ordering of all listed books see Note 4. |
LT:L34(21):151 |
| 5. | Tape 1 - The
Teaching Company's Three
part Philosophy
of Religion; 18 cassetttes
(36 lectures), 3 course guidebooks
(CG1, CG2, & CG3), and 3 transcript books (TB1,
TB2, & TB3); all by Professor
James H. Hall, Ph.D.
Use to test any Religion's
consistency and logic. Tape 2 - The
Teaching Company's Biology
and Human Behavior: The Neurological Origins of Individuality;
Tape 3 - The Teaching Company's God and Mankind: Comparative Religions; 4 cassettes (8 lectures), Course Buidebook (CG1); all by Professor Robert Oden, Ph.D. Tape 4 - The Teaching Company's Einstein’s Relativity and the Quantum Revolution: Modern Physics for Nonscientists; 12 cassetes (24 lectures), 2 course guidebooks (CG1 & CG2), and 2 transcript books (TB1 & TB2); all as taught by Prof. Richard Wolfson, Ph.D. Tape 5 - The Teaching
Company's Two part Particle
Physics for Non-Physicists: A Tour of the Microcosmos;
|
I highly recommend
these tapes. |
| 6. | Kindly send e-mail
for clarification request, disagreement, or suggestion for additions to Glossary to josephb@yesselman.com |
|
| 7. | Suggestion: Do
not read this Glossary as you would a novel but rather select a head-word or Topic and then follow all its links in turn wherever they may lead. You will then be putting hypertexting to its fullest and best advantage—the fuller discussion of a thread. If you do not stick to one thread at a time, this Web Site will be very convoluted, confusing, and an annoying maze. If you prefer to read linearly, read these plain vanilla text versions, abridged versions, e-book versions, or best, study the printed book—book page numbers are given for most scanned books. For further Topics to follow see
Terry
Neff 's "Topic
Index". |
Durant's
Story
EL:[3]:vi |
| 8. | The secret to understanding
Spinoza is to POSIT (as a working
hypothesis) "1D6
= ONE"
— Synthesized. The Foundation Rock. TEI:[104]:38, JBYnote1. Spinoza's MOTIVE for everything he says, is to lay the groundwork for teaching the "Organic interdependence of Parts." Remember this and all his puzzling sayings, for example G-D, become more, if not completely, understandable. Spinozistic insights in a nutshell: 1. °Perpetuation and Conatus (ultimately PcM) 2. °JOY. 3. °LOVE. 4. Self-interest and Enlightenment. 5. Religion and °Peace-of-Mind. 6. Organic Interdependence. 7. Cash (effective) Value. If I have not gotten these across, I have failed to explain Spinoza or to achieve my Purpose. |
TEI:[16]:7 TEI:[38]:14 TEI:[49:3]:17 TEI:[105]:38 I:1.5a D:1.7 Meditate on. |
Abstractions: G-D, Deus, Being, ONE, J---vah, Allah, Buddha, Krishna, Jesus, Mary, Hampshire202, Language, Fences, Foundation Rock.
A picture is worth a thousand words (abstractions).
RH—n. 1. an abstract or general idea
or term. 2. the act of considering something in terms of general qualities
or characteristics, apart from concrete realities,
specific objects, or actual instances. 6. the quality of being abstract.
[1540-50; < LL]
RH—1. thought of apart from concrete realities, specific objects, or actual instances: an abstract idea. 2. expressing a quality or characteristic apart from any specific object or instance: an abstract word like justice. 3. theoretical; not applied or practical. 4. difficult to understand; abstruse. 9. something that concentrates in itself the essential qualities of anything more extensive or more general.
[1400-50; late ME: withdrawn from worldly interests < ML abstractus, L: ptp. of abstrahere to drag away, divert = abs- ABS - + trahere to draw, pull; cf. TRACT 1]
ACCELERATION
, I:Table 1, I:Table
3, I:1.7, I:1.11,
D:1.23d.
RH— a change in velocity,
the time rate of change of velocity
with respect to magnitude or direction; the
derivative of velocity
with respect to
time.
OUP— the rate of
change of velocity measured in terms of a
unit of time.
I use °ACCELERATION
to serve as an analogy for °FAITH.
I:Table
1. Negative values are deceleration
and "lack of faith."
Bk.XIV:1:xxiii.
Active,
E3:I:130,
Passive, E1:XXIX(8):68,
E3:I(8):13, E3:III:135,
E3:XI(2):138,
E3:GN(2)N,
E4:XXIII:204, E4:XXVIII(2):205,
E4:Ap.II:236, E5:IV(7):249,
E5:XLII(1):270, EL:[54]:xxvi.
E3:Def.II:129—
Bk.XIV:2:1931.
]are active
[
I say that we act when anything takes
place, either within
Active
emotion
us
or externally to us, whereof we are
the adequate
cause; that
is (by the foregoing definition) when through
Hanpshire:135—affectus
our
nature something takes place within us or externally
to us, which can through our
nature alone be clearly and
distinctly understood
{PcM}.
{ Example— Your TV is broken
Mark
Twain
and you know how
to fix it; and do or do not fix it
based on other
priorities. E3:GN:2n.
{Active—understanding
and having Peace of Mind;
Passive—not
understanding with loss of PcM.}
Spinoza's
Religion
E1:XXIX(8):68—
"I wish here
to explain, what we should understand
by
Nature viewed
as active (natura Naturans {G-D})
{Explained
E1:
XXIX(9)},
and nature viewed as passive (natura naturata
{G-d})."
{ Explained
E1:XXIX(10):69 }
< Endnote
39, Bk.XV:267.
>
Bk.III:202.
E3:Def.III:130—Passion.
]affectus[
]affections [
"By emotions
I mean the modifications of the body, whereby
Bk.XIV:2:1931.
the active
power of said body is
increased or diminished,
aided or constrained,
and also the ideas of such
modifica-
tions."
N.B. If we
can be the adequate cause
of any of these
E3:GN:2n.
modifications, I
then call the emotion an activity, otherwise
I call it a passion, or state
wherein the mind is passive.
{Active—understanding
and having Peace of Mind;
Passive—not
understanding with loss of PcM.}
Spinoza's
Religion
Neff
Adequate
- Inadequate, Idea,
TEI:[29]:11, TEI:[35]:13,
TEI:[73]:27,
E2:XXXIV:108, E3:I:130, E5:XVII(1):255,EL:[50]:xxvi, EL:[54]:xxvi, EL:[60]:xxix,
TTP2:Note 8, TEI:L64(60):395, Common Notions.
E3:Def.I:129—adequate
cause, efficient cause—Bk.XIX:22112.
"Def. I. By an adequate
cause, I mean a cause through
which its effect
can be clearly
and distinctly perceived.
Descartes—Bombardi
By an inadequate
or partial cause, I mean a cause
through which, by
itself, its effect cannot be understood."
Hampshire:135—affectus
Bk.III:79—TEI:L64(60):395,
TEI:[35], [73]:13;
Bk.XIX:22112.
E2:Def.IV:82—adequate
Idea, clearly
and distinctly
{Real},
common notion—
{Bk.XIV:2:101—TEI:L64(60):395.
Examples: POSIT
—organic.}
<Bk.XV:289221on
TEI[62]—Parkinson:27383,
84 on
E2:XXVIII:105>
]G:Shirley:2513—ideate,
E2:XLVIII(8)
& XLIX:120, E1:XXX:(1):69
[
"Def. IV. By
an adequate Idea, I
mean an idea which,
in so far as it is considered
in itself, without relation to the
object,
has all the properties or intrinsic marks ]character-
istics[
of a true idea." {
An axiomatic
idea such as the hypothesis
of G-D, E4:Ap.II:236,
E3:GN(2)n,
Confused idea,
Prejudice
, NeffEL:L04(04):282,
NeffEL:42(37):360.}
How
the Rationalists Construe "Clear and Distinct Ideas".
Descartes—Bombardi
From Dijn's Bk.III:53—Parkinson's Book XV:27484
"Yet this
kind of knowing is not really adequate (a Spinozistic
Reason—knowing
term indicating complete
knowledge of a thing)
because it
by it's properties.
does not lead
to a real insight into the essence
of things".
Intuition—knowing
{Complete knowledge
of a thing is knowing, by intuition,
its immanent cause;
by it's essence.
i.e. it's essence
not it's properties. E3:Def.III:130,
E3:GN(2):185, E3:GN2n.}
{CashValue
- Studying Spinoza's definitions
(hypotheses)
increases "adequate
knowledge" and
thus °PcM.}
WikipediA,
Introduction. Ridley's
Altruism.
Altruism,
D:1.35,
Charity,
Duty, ONE,
Pity, D:1.8, D:1.33b,
D:1.34a, D:1.35a,
Sign Names,
E3:LIX(6):172,
E2:Endnote 3, HirPent:Gn
43:14, Mark
Twain—Altruism
does not Exist,
Egoism,
Ayn Rand, Dawkin's:546,
Ridley:3,
Altruism
never exists, except it be an act of illness. When
you say
"I love
you", it is (see D:1.33c) a
euphemism for "I need you, and
An unfaced
truth.
the more
or less I
need you the more or less
will I love you."
Dawkins2:Genes
That is why there are marriages;
that is why there are divorces.
Substitute the word 'need'
for 'love' and you will understand 'love'
in its full dimensions. There
is no such thing as altruism, except it
Mark Twain
be an act of illness.
If the lung did not take its "take"; it would soon
die, leading to the death of
the whole organism. You would
not rely
organic
on a sick lung that does not use any
of the blood it passes through
for its own use.
The Law of Organisms requires interdependence.
derogatory
Uzgalis - Hobbes
I hasten to
add that this
is not pejorative;
but the Law
of Organisms. Ridley's
Altruism
Example: Even MotherTeresa
fulfills her inner need
first and
R. Hillel
then those she aids,
second. That does not make her work
any
less meritorious;
the poor woman in Mark
Twain's story was aided.
Mark Twain
Self-interest—"you
have to give to
get; you have to get to give"
Ayn
Rand
is the nature
of organic
interdependence. Altruism
implies
that
a person is not always
part of G-D
and has, at that time, no duties
Extinction
or obligations.
I have read "In all of history, no one ever washed
a rented car," and Dawkin's:546
I have added, except when the dirty
car reflected on him.
E4:L:221—
Pity, in a man
who lives under the guidance of reason,
is in itself bad and useless. {Pity
as defined herein.}
RH— the principle or practice of unselfish
concern for the welfare
of others ( opposed to egoism
). { I
believe it is, by and large,
opposed to rationalism.
}
[1850-55; others]
Neff
, Bk.XIV:1:xiii, xv.
Attribute,
I:1.4b, I:1.5b, Mode,
Analogy,G–D,
TTP3:XIII(16):176,
Calculus:5:1,
E1:XVI:59,EL:[42,
43]:xxiii., Neff
EL:L04(04):282,
Bk.XIX:1612.
Ethics:Part I:Def. IV:45— Bk.XIV:1:141, 224.
By attribute,
I mean that which the intellect perceives as
Durant:637
constituting the essence
of substance. Robinson5:40
Bk.VII:234- Attribute—Essence of Substance:
In its common meaning, this
word indicates that which is
attributed to, or predicated
of, a subject; a quality of that
subject. But in the Ethics
Spinoza uses it almost in a
special sense, defining it as that
which the intellect per-
ceives as constituting
the essence of substance.
Now TEI:[97]:36
since substance
is by definition infinite, it must have in-
finite attributes; but of these
the human intellect perceives
only two, extension
and thought. That is
to say, what- Synthesize
ever we perceive
as real must come under
these two
headings, extension and thought.
{ E2:I
& E2:II:83.
}
Calculus:Fig.3
RH— a quality, character,
characteristic, or property attributed
as belonging to a
person, thing, group, etc.: Sensitivity and
eyesight are attributes { In
its common meaning }.
OUP— Spinoza's doctrine is that
there is one infinite substance
of which extension
and thought are attributes. {
Sensitivity and
eyesight are Modes
of Attributes. }
[1350-1400; allot, assign, attribute, classify]
Awareness,
Insight, Cash Value,
Organic, °BELIEF,
D:1.28, E3:D.6N,
Mysticism,
Consciousness, Intellectual
Love of G-D, Enlightenment.
WikipediA,
Britannica
Axiom, I:1.3,
Euclidean,
Knowledge,
I:1.4, I:1.6,
I:1.7, D:1.4,
D:2.2,
TEI:[38]:14, TEI:[93]:34,
Ethics:Part 1: Ax.
I to VII, Common
Notion.
TEI:[70]:26—
TEI:[97]:36—
"The rules for the definition of an uncreated {infinite} thing are ..."
{Axioms
are the standard for defining
finite things; and also,
the E2:Parkinson:27490
yardstick
for measuring their intensities.}
{PERPETUATION and its identities are axioms.}
RH— a self-evident
truth that requires no proof, a proposition
in logic or mathematics that
is assumed without proof for the
sake of studying the consequences
that followfrom it. {posit,
postulate.}
[worthy]
WikipediA,
°BEAUTY,
I:1.2a , Calculus:Fig.1(b),
°UGLY, I:2.5c,
EL:L15(32):290,
E1:Shirley:609.
For
instance, if the motion whose objects
we see commu-
Durant:640
nicate to our nerves {parasympathetic
nervous system}
be conducive
to health {°P},
the objects causing it are styled beautiful;
if a
contrary motion be excited {sympathetic
nervous system},
they are
styled ugly.
{Good,
Final Causes}
{°BEAUTY is function.
Its intensity is pro-
portional to the increase
in °PERPETUATION
Aesthetics
caused.
G:Notes
1 &2.
Beauty
is truth, truth is beauty;
these are identities. Above is a
spinozistic definition
(hypothesis).}
RH— {Positive
values}
the quality present in a person or thing
that gives intense
aesthetic pleasure or deep satisfaction;
advantage, asset, attraction, feature,
good thing, excellence,
benefit, grace, boon; attractiveness,
splendor, resplendence,
magnificence, radiance. {
Negative values }
ugliness,repulsiveness,
unpleasantness; disadvantage, detraction,
shortcoming, flaw.
[1225-75; fine]
WikipediA,
BEING,
G-D, being,
5P17, Hebrew, Spinoza's
Religion,
WikipediA,
Britannica,
°BELIEF,
°FAITH, faith,
Hypothesis,
Religion, Mark
Twain, William
James,
Pragmatic, Cash
Value,I:1.11ff,
Awareness, °LOVE, °HATE,
TTP3:XIII(47):180—
". . . . . we
cannot, therefore, think that opinions
taken in Garbage
In, Garbage out.
themselves without respect
to actions are either pious or
Credulity,
impious, but must
maintain that a man is pious or impious
in his beliefs
only in so far as he is thereby
incited to
Pragmatism
obedience,
or derives from them license to sin
and rebel."
From "How to Make our Ideas Clear" by Charles Peirce.
{Religions}
And what, then, is belief? It is the
demi-cadence which closes
Mark
Twain
a musical phrase in the symphony of our intellectual
life. We
Credulity
have seen that it has just three
properties: First, it is some-
{All
try to achieve
thing that we are aware of; second,
it appeases the irritation PEACE
OF MIND—
of doubt; and, third,
it involves the establishment in our nature
the basis of religion.}
of a rule of action, or,
say for short, a habit.
Psychology:[5]
{A
belief (hypothesis) in its
varying degrees, can be a guess,
a dogma,
a hope, an intuition,
a leap-of-faith. Belief
is to make an
hypothesis which then must pass
the test of Cash Value—bringing
Peace
of Mind (PcM, Religion).}
RH—something believed; opinion; conviction; confidence
in the
truth or existence of something not
immediately susceptible to
rigorous proof; confidence; faith;
trust: a religious creed or faith.
firm notion, view, theory, persuasion;
conclusion; assumption,
supposition, presumption, feeling, expectation, judgment,
impres-
sion, hypothesis, deduction,
inference, guess. { Note
the differences
in degree.}
[1150-1200; believe]
Neff,
WikipediA, Bk.XIV:1:xxiv,
xxv.
Blessedness,
Salvation, °PcM,
Religion, Serenity,
Intellectual love of G-D, Loves
G-D,
E2:(Prf):82, E2:XLIX(62):126, E5:(Prf:2):244, E5:XXXIII(4):264, E5:XXXVI(3)n:265, E5:XLII:270, TTP1:III(48):48, TTP1:IV(25-37):59, Highest Good, BkX:56, EL:[61]:xxx, Purpose—PcM, Enlightened, E5:Wolfson:2:311—Liberty.
E4:(Ap.IV):237—EL:Wolfson:2:3084—EL:[60]:xxix;
E5:Dijn:26113
on E4:Dijn:247;Bk.XX:19023;
GRACE
Bk.XIX:130a—beatitude—E5:Deleuze:130a.
In life, therefore, it is especially
useful to perfect, as far as
we can our intellect, or
reason. In this one thing consists
man's
highest happiness,
or blessedness.
Indeed E5:Dijn:257-
8
blessedness
is nothing else but the satisfaction {peace}
of Glory—E5:Endnote36:4
the mind that stems from the
intuitive knowledge
of G-D.
But perfecting the intellect
is nothing but understanding
ST:Wolfson:2:3113
G-D, his attributes,
and his actions (emphasis added).
Bk.XIX:130a—beatitude—E5:Deleuze:130a.
E5:XXXIII(4):264—EL:Wolfson:2:3084—EL:[60]:xxix.
If pleasure
consists in the transition to a greater perfection,
assuredly blessedness
must consist in the mind being
Peace-of-Mind
endowed with perfection
itself. { E5:Parkinson:285175
}
Spinoza's
Religion
RH— 1. to consecrate or sanctify
by a religious rite; make or pro-
nounce holy. 2. to request God's
divine favor upon or for: Bless this
house. 3. to bestow some benefit upon; endow:
Nature blessed me
with strong teeth. 4. to extol as holy;
glorify: Bless the name of the
Lord. 5. to protect or guard
from evil (usu. used interjectionally):
Bless you!. 6. to make the sign of the cross over or
upon.
[bef. 950; ME; OE bletsian, bledsian to consecrate, orig.
with blood,
earlier * blodisoian, der. of blod BLOOD]
WikipediA,
BOREDOM, I:Table
2, I:1.1, I:1.6,
I:1.10, D:1.19ff,
D:1.21.
{BOREDOM is no change
in °Perfection. I:2.5c
It marks the theoretical
transition
from JOY to SORROW and
Calculus:Fig.1(a)
vice versa. Calculus:Fig.
2. }
RH— the state of being bored, tedium, ennui,
dullness, monot-
ony, doldrums, weariness, indifference, impassiveness,
apathy.
{ Note
that the synonyms for BOREDOM, unlike those for °JOY
and °SORROW,
vary not
in degree. } °EMOTION
= 0, I:Table
2, I:1.6.
OUP— lack of interest or
attention; a matter of indifference;
neutrality.
WikipediA,
Britannica
Calculus, Infinitesimal
Calculus, Derivative, Waves,
I:1.3
Calculus deals with rates-of-change which °EMOTION
and °FAITH
are. Calculus notation
is useful for expressing Spinozistic
definitions
involving rates-of-change.
RH— a method of calculation,
esp. one of several highly
systematic methods of treating problems by a
special system
of algebraic notations, as differential
or integral calculus.
OUP— the infinitesimal
calculuses of differentiation: differential
calculus – Math. an infinitesimal
difference between success-
ive values of a variable; a function expressingthis
as a rate of
change with respect to another variable.
Etymology L, = small stone used in reckoning on an abacus
[1610-20; < L: pebble, small stone
(used in reckoning) = calc-,
s. of calx limestone]
Final
Causes—Bk.XIV:1:xix,
WikipediA, Britannica.
Cause, G:Note 1,
definition, hypothesis,D:2.11ff,
I:2.5c, TEI:[92]:34,
Calculus:6.2b & c,
E3:Def.I:129, E3:De.VI:175, True Idea, Bk.XIV:1:xvi, Understanding, Cause in itself. E1:XVIII:62—Causality.
G:Shirley:2512
- Cause (causa). EL:L21(73):297,
adequate cause.
E1:Parkinson:2602
Bk.XIV:2:1432—TEI:[96(3)]:35,
proximate cause.
Robinson3:170
"The reader will find that
Spinoza's "cause" is not quite
Hampshire:136—affectus
what he is used to. It need not imply
temporal succession:
indeed, for Spinoza a cause
is more logical
ground from
or hypothesis
which a consequent follows, . . . "For
example, it "follows"
from the nature of
a triangle that its three angles are
Durant:639
equal to two right angles.
{ When
there is an increase in °P,
°JOY
and °LOVE
are indwelling—inseparable
consequences; when there
is a
decrease in °P,
°SORROW and °HATE
are indwelling—inseparable
con-
sequences
}." Hence, Spinoza occasionally
couples the word
"cause" with the term "reason"
("ratio").
Bk.III:204.
By the phrase "efficient
cause" Spinoza means
primarily Stewart06:[4]
the cause that produces the
effect in question and is
quite close to the notion
of a sufficient
condition. His
theory of causality excludes
the Aristotelian final cause,
the goal or purpose
of a thing or event. In his Appendix
to Part I Spinoza explicitly
claims that final
causes are
human
fictions.
E1:Parkinson:2602.
Bk.XIV:1:111, 319,
322, 323,324.
The phrases "immanent cause"
(causa immanens) and
Mark
Twain
"transitive cause"
(causa transiens) appear in E1:XVIII.
A transitive cause is one in which causation
"passes over"
from the cause to the effect, while cause and effect
remain
really distinct. Mechanical causation would
be an example
of transitive causation; e.g. one billiard
ball hitting another
into the pocket. An immanent cause,
however, is an "in-
Important
dwelling
cause," one that is inseparable
from its effect. For
example, the numbers 1 and 2 are immanent causes of
the
number 4 insofar as
they are factors of it. Although 1 and
2 can be separated out of 4 by analysis,
they are never-
theless always "in" it. It is
Spinoza's thesis that G-D
is the
Durant:639
immanent, not
the transitive cause of all things.
This is the
Analogy—A
fetus.
denial
of the traditional idea of
God as the creative, tran-
scendent cause
of the world. Insofar as G-D is the unique
substance of which
everything else is a mode,
all modes
will be in
G-D and G-D will
be their indwelling cause."
Logos - 1 John 1:1
{ The
unsynthesized argument
between creationism
and evolutionism
Bk.XXI—Both
is embodied in
the above—transcendence
versus immanence.
New Wine
in Old Bottles—E1:BWolfson:1:158;
Spinozistic
meaning—D2:Dijn:265;
Important
Pragmatism,
Burden
of TTP, EL:[60]:xxix,
Analogy—with
JOY is LOVE. }
< E1:Parkinson:2602
>; Bk.XX:19024.
< E1:Parkinson:2601
>
{Properties}
{Dictionary definitions are,
in Spinoza's terms, "transitive
causes".
G:Note 1
In Spinoza's
definitions, "causes"
are immanent causes.
An immanent
cause is an "indwelling
cause," one
that is
inseparable
from its effect—say, a fetus turning
into a Man.
E1:XVIII:62
An transient cause
is when one billiard ball hits another—both
bodies apparently remain
the same afterwards. I say apparently
because in reality
there are no transitive causes; for all things
are in a constant, however slow,
state of flux, even billiard balls.}
RH— bring about, lead to, give rise
to, bring to pass, produce,
generate, create, effect, make,
provoke, incline, precipitate;
motivate, incite, stimulate, stir
up, impel, inspire.
OUP— that which produces an effect, or gives rise to an
action,
phenomenon, or condition.
[1175-1225; reason, sake, case]
Britannica.
see
Charity,
Pity,
Altruism, Compassion,
Holy, Mercy,
Organic, Piety,
Equity, Self-interest,
Mother Theresa, TTP1:V(18):71,
E4:L:221.
{ The Hebrew word
which is often mis-translated
as charity,
Mark Twain
mercy, pity,
etc., is tsed-aw-kaw', Strong:6666—rightness,
justice, virtue,
piety. The root
of tsed-aw-kaw' is tsaw-dak',
Strong:6663—upright,
just, straight, innocent, true, sincere; (the
same
root as for righteousness).
Based on this etymology,
'I-thee' Relation
it is what one
lung does when the other
collapses; it does
double-duty, not
out of altruism, but for
its very own survival.
Analogy
In so doing, it is, if
possible, leading the collapsed lung back to
health and thereby
increasing the lung-capacity of the body.
It is the Golden
Rule in working clothes; enlightened self-interest.}
Uzgalis - Hobbes
TTP3:XIV(17):183,
Organic,Ridley's
Altruism.
RH— donations or generous actions to aid the poor, ill,
or help-
less; benevolent feeling, esp. toward
those in need; to do
something out of charity; leniency
in judging others; forbear-
ance; alms; Christian love {altruistic?};
agape { altruistic?,
nonerotic
love, as of God
for humankind or of humankind for God or for one another.}
[1125-75; ME charite < OF < L caritas = car (us)
dear {affection,
love, esteem}+ -itas - ITY]
In Latin "Charistia"
a festival celebrated among the Romans on
Thanksgiving Day
February 22, the chief object
of which was the reconcilement of
would be
family disagreements: from Cassell's
Latin Dictionary.
a good day.
WikipediA,
Britannica,
Commandment,
Duty, Obedience, Piety, Sacred,
Divine Law+1,
Mark Twain,
TTP4:XVII(49):219, D1:HirLev
19:18, Word of G-D,
TTP1:Smith:109.
{ The Hebrew word for commandment
is mits-vaw', Strong:4687
Hirsch
—a command, an ordinance,
a precept, good deed. The root
of mits-vaw' is
tsaw-vaw', Strong:6680—to enjoin, bid, send a
Includes
messenger, put
in order, to charge
with. A related word is
Scientific Laws.
tsaw-vaw', Strong:6633—to
mass an army, fight, war; army,
host. Based on
this etymology, a commandment is an order
to a part
of an organism to do
its duty for the sake of the
organism's perpetuation.
Enlightened self-interest
is the better
reason
for obeying the command, not fear
of punishment.
See three
injunctions.}
Bk.XIV:1:xxiii.,
Bk.III:240.
Conatus,
Perpetuation,
Secret, EL:[55]:xxvii,
E2:Wolfson:178,
E3:Endnote 6:0, 6:0a,
& 11:0,
Bk.XV:278111
onE3:VI:136,
Bk.XV:278112on
E3:VII:136, D:1.7,
E4:Dijn:34,
First
law of nature, Increased or Diminished,
MarkTwain,
Langer.
{From Cassell's
Latin Dictionary: conatus— an exertion, effort; an impulse,
Damasio—biological
inclination; an undertaking. Elwes'
translation of "conatus" is "endeavour."
[strives],3P4—inertia,
E3:Dijn:240.}
Hampshire:141,
179, 208e.
E3:VI:136—Preservation, Perpetuation, E3:Wolfson:2:204. Freud's Libido
Everything, in so far as it is in
itself {no
external object causing
Nutshell
deterioration},
endeavours to persist in its own being
Robinson3:15,
Robinson3:109
{by
perpetuating its genes; see
Dawkins2:Genes
and Salmon}. Robinson3:59
{Except,
perhaps, radioactive materials—radium? I do not know.}
E3:VII:136— Bk.XIX:233conatus.
The endeavour
{ conatus,
I:1.5a },
wherewith everything en-
deavours to
persist in its own being,
is nothing else but
Damasio—biological
the actual essence
of the thing in question.
RH—connate. existing in a person or
thing from birth or origin;
inborn. associated in birth or origin. allied or agreeing
in nature;
cognate. firmly united; fused. congenitally
joined, as leaves.
[1635-45;<LL connatus, ptp. of connasci to be born
at the same
time with = L con- CON - + nasci to be
born; see NASCENT]
OUP—connate. existing in a person or
thing from birth; innate.
formed at the same time.
WikimediA,
Deduction,
I:2.1,TTP1:V(66):76,
E2:XLVII(3):118, Hypothesis,
Insight, Bombardi.
TEI:[19:5]:8—
Lastly, there is
the perception arising when
a thing is per-
E2:Prkinson:27490
ceived solely
through its essence, {
by intuition,
i.e. knowing
G-D}
OR {
then
through deduction;
by the knowing of G-D
} the
{ Posit:
1D6 = ONE;
knowledge
of its { the
thing's } proximate
cause.
Organic—deduce
Bk.XIV:2:1432—TEI:[96(3)]:35
^
Interdependence
}
From Peter Berger's "Rumor of Angels"—Deduction
I use induction to mean any process of thought that begins with experience. Deduction is the reverse process; it begins with ideas that precede experience. By "inductive faith," then, I mean a religious process of thought that begins with facts of human experience; conversely, "deductive faith" begins with certain assumptions (notably assumptions about divine revelation) that cannot be tested by experience. Put simply; inductive faith moves from human experience to statements about God {or G-D}, deductive faith from statements about God {or G-D} to interpretations of human experience.
{
à
priori
}
RH—inference from the general to the particular;
a conclusion
reached by this process; conclusion,
inference, assumption,
presumption, judgment, supposition,
interpretation, analysis,
calculation; understanding, comprehension,
reflection, guess,
speculation, consideration.
Compare INDUCTION.
OUP— the inferring of particular instances
from a general law.
I:2.6B
Neff,
WikipediA,
Definition,
Hypothesis, I:2.5c,
axiom, cause, I:1.1ff,
D:1.3ff, D:1.26b,
D:2.13, D:2.11ff,
TEI:[92-97]:34,
E1:VIII(17):49, The
Pragmatic Method.
E3:Def. of the Emotions XX:Explanation:178— < E1:Parkinson:2601 >
"But my purpose
is to explain, not the meaning of
words
Spinoza's
Religion
{ by
their properties },
but the nature
of things {
by their
causes }."
TEI:[94]
{ G:Notes
1 & 2, Example
°JOY—°LOVE;
°SORROW—°HATE.
More examples.
See common parlance. }
TEI:[95]:35—
"A definition,
if it is to be called perfect, must
explain the
inmost essence
of a thing {
its cause
} and must take care
not
to substitute for this any of
its properties." {
I:2.2b
I:2.5c }
TEI:[97]:36—
TEI:[96]:35—
"If the thing
in question be created { finite
}, the definition
must.....comprehend the proximate
cause." {
G:Note
1 & 2.
}
Definitions which
define things by their causes
are hypotheses;
Stipulations
they all need be suspect,
for they are only congealed hypotheses.
1P1
They need to
be constantly updated as knowledge
evolves.
RH— the act of making definite,
distinct, or clear; the formal
statement of the meaning or
significance of a word,
phrase,
I:1.5a
Neff,
WikimediA, Britannica
Biology
of Emotions—ANS, James'
Bear, Robinson3:109.
Definitions of the
Emotions - E3:Def:173,
E3:GenDef:185,
E3:Pfc(12):129.
"I have made a ceaseless effort not to ridicule
(mock), not to bewail,
not to scorn
human actions {
emotions },
but to understand them."
{Carefully
study these Definitions and see how
they help you
Mark Twain
understand "human
actions," including your own. }
Bk.XX:189.
{All these terms
are here fully Capitalized in accordance
with
G:Notes 1
&2.
Prefix the degree sign (°) before each of them.}
Common
Parlance, Mark
Twain. <E1:Parkinson:2601,
Bk.XV:277106—E3:DefEmo:173>
LeDoux96:43
AMBITION,
ANGER, APPETITE,
APPROVAL, AVARICE,
AVERSION,
LeDoux96:113
BENEVOLENCE,
COMPASSION, CONFIDENCE,
CONSTER-
Hampshire:138
NATION, CONTEMPT, COURAGE,
COURTESY, COWARDICE,
CRUELTY, DARING,
DERISION, DESIRE,
DESPAIR, DEVO-
TION, DISAPPOINTMENT,
DISPARAGEMENT, EMULATION,
ENVY,
FEAR, HATRED,
HONOUR,
HOPE, HUMILITY+1,
INCLIN-
ATION, INDIGNATION,
INTEMPERANCE, JEALOUSY,
JOY,
{Spinoza's
LOVE,
LUST, LUXURY,
MELANCHOLY,
MEMORY,
MERRIMENT
definitions}
PAIN,
PARTIALITY, PITY,
PLEASURE, PRIDE,
REGRET,
REPENTANCE,
REVENGE, SAVAGENESS,
SELF-ABASEMENT,
SELF-APPROVAL,
SHAME, SIN,
STIMULATION,
SUFFERING,
SYMPATHY,
THANKFULNESS,
TIMIDITY,
VACILLATION,
WONDER,
DOUBT, DISDAIN,
MODESTY, GRATITUDE,
DEFERENCE ,
CLEMENCY , VENERATION
, HORROR, SCORN,
SELF-COMPLACENCY , IMPUDENCE
, DEFERENCE ,
BASE,
HIGH-MINDEDNESS,
INFIRMITY, MIRTH+1.
Britannica
Derivative,
Calculus, Modification,
Emotion, Mode, Change,
I:1.6, I:1.7
RH— the instantaneous
rate-of-change of one quantity in a
function with respect to another.
OUP— a quantity measuring the rate-of-change of another.
{First derivative:
°VELOCITY is the instantaneous
change of °DISTANCE.
°EMOTION is the instantaneous change of °P.
Calculus:Fig. 2.
Second derivative:
°ACCELERATiON is
the instantaneous change of
°VELOCITY. The change
is caused by an external
object—gas.
°FAITH
is the instantaneous change of °EMOTION,
with the awareness
of the cause. The change is
caused
by an external object—say, a
person, an
object, or an idea.
Third derivative: Calculus:Table 1, Note 4 , I:1.8 }
WikimediA,
Determinism, Free-Will, Free-Choice,
Circumstance,
L:[48], Britannica,
2P49,
EndnoteDeVII, Mark
Twain, Other Determinism Links,
Stace:125, Popkin:71
- repent,
Ripley:309.
Determinism is the philosophical doctrine which claims that every physical event, including human thinking and action, is causally determined by an unbroken chain of prior occurrences. Fatalism—Ridley:307
According to Laplace,
probabilities arise from our ignorance. The
world is deterministic, so the
probability of a possible event depends on our limited information about
it rather than on the causal
forces that determine whether it shall occur.
You have no Free-Will to act against Nature.
(You have no Free-Will to not, someday, die.) But
you may? have Free-Choice to do something
doable. (You fall in love with someone
and it changes your whole life. I met my wife at a
football game.) I say, may, because (at
our present state of knowledge) it is unknowable that
you had Free-Choice and was not
compelled
by your hardware (nature, temperament,
genes) and software (nurture,
experiences, education, training).
Free-Choice (a decision based on your hard wiring and data base) means you are compelled by seemingly random "Exterior Influences" to act in a certain way. Just as seemingly random mutations affect species, so seeming random "Outside Influences" affect your future. I say 'seemingly' because it is only a lack of knowledge of the chain of causes that keeps you from understandingthe known effect.
As an analogy, you have the choice a computer has as it is makes a decision based on its data base. Remember: Garbage in (false subjectivity) is garbage out.
The cash Value of positing 'No Free-Will' and 'No Free-Choice', i.e. Determinism, is that it provides the logic for hypothesizing 'no praise, no blame'. (The criminal should not be blamed in the same way one who has scarlet fever is not blamed—but in both cases, society does protects itself by incarceration or quarantine. A genius should not be praised; an idiot should not be blamed. See Spinoza's Dictum.) Also by providing the logic for diligent study to discover the causes (such as the human genome project) of behavior.
The cash value for those that posit 'Free-Will' and Free-Choice is pedagogic exhortation to behave by providing the logic for 'award and punishment' (supposedly to keep people from going berserk if there is to be no blame placed).
RH— 1. a doctrine that all facts and events exemplify natural laws. 2. a doctrine that all events have necessary and sufficient causes. (Necessary cause—you need to be an American citizen in good standing to get an American passport; Sufficient cause—you need pay $75 to get an American passport.)
Neff,
WikipediA, Britannica.
°DESIRE,
appetite—instinct
(Appetitus),
E3:XXXVII:155, E4:Def.VII:191,
E5:IV(7):249,
EL:[55]:xxvii, TTP1(3:21):45.E3:De.I:173—
"Desire is the actual essence
of a man, in so far as it {
he }
MarkTwain
is conceived, as
determined to a particular activity {
say, Robinson3:15
to eat }
by some given modification
ofitself { himself,
when
Will
& Desire
he becomes hungry }.
"Explanation. – ... appetite
is the essence of man, in so
far as it {
he
} is determined
to act {,
if RATIONAL }
in a way
tending to promote its {
his }
own persistence."
E3:IX:137—
". . . Desire is appetite with consciousness
thereof."
{G:Note
1 }
E4:Def.VII:191—
"By an end, for the sake of
which we do something,
I mean a desire."
RH— { Positive
values } sexual
appetite or a sexual urge, a longing
or craving, as for something
that brings satisfaction, want, to
ask for, solicit, request.
{ Negative values
} dislike, distaste, decline,
spurn, refuse, reject, repudiate,
aversion. { Note
how everyday
language expresses the
varying positive and negative intensities with another
synonym.
G:Note 1 }
[1200-50; to long for, require]
WikipediA,
Dogma,
I:2.8c, I:2.13b,BkX:56,
Quibble,
EL:[64]:xxxi,
Christian Dogmas,
TTP3:XIV(39):185,
TTP3:XIV(43,
45, 47):186,
TTP4:XVII(49):219.
E1:Wolfson:1:158—UntenableHypothesis, Anti-Semitism.
{A useful
or non-useful hypothesis
assumed true in the face of
contradictions or unsubstantiated
proof of inferences made.
Prejudices
It is true
if useful; false and idolatrous
if otherwise.} Pragmatism
RH— a system of principles or tenets, as of a church;
a specific
tenet or doctrine authoritatively
put forth, as by a church; pre-
scribed doctrine: political dogma; an established
belief or prin-
ciple. You can't
embrace a religion without
accepting its
dogmas: doctrine, teachings, set
of beliefs, principles, philos-
ophy; convictions, credo, tenet.
OUP— a principle, tenet, or system of these, esp.
as laid down
by the authority of
a Church; such principles collectively; an
arrogant declaration of opinion.
[1590-1600; to seem, think, seem good, opinion.]
WikipediA,
Duty,
D:1.34a, Altruism,
Sacred,
Commandment, Piety,
ONE, Obedience
& Self-interest,
TTP1:V(55):75,
TTP3:XV(3):190, TTP4:XVII(49):219,
TTP4:XIX(39,42):249,
TTP3:XIV(17):183—D1:HirLev
19:18.
"Moreover, the
Bible teaches very clearly in a great many
passages what everyone ought
to do in order to obey G-D;
the whole duty
is summed up in love to one's
neighbour.
{ the
Golden Rule, Mark Twain}."
{A completely free
man fulfills his function not out of duty but
E4:Dijn:246.
of the knowledge that he is
a part of an organism just as the
heart of his
body. A part of an organism,
an orchestra, a
Own
Sake
country, all have
their function to perform for their very own
good—it
is not altruism.}
Mark
Twain
E4:LX(1):228,
E4:Ap.XVII:239.
RH— something that one is expected or required to do by
moral
or legal obligation, an action
or task required by a person's
position or occupation, the respectful and obedient conduct
due
a parent, elder, or superior, a task or chore that one is
expected
to perform, an assigned military task,
occupation, or place of
service, the military service required
of a citizen by a country.
[1250-1300; duete. See DUE, - TY ]
Ego,
External, Id, E3:Def.II:129,
Egoism—Britannica,
WikipediA,
RH— the " I " or self of any person; a
thinking, feeling, and
con-
scious being, able to distinguish itself from other selves
{or even
itself}.
Psychoanal. the conscious, rational
component of the
psyche that experiences and reacts
to the outside world and
mediates between the demands of the id
and superego; Philos.
- the enduring and
conscious element that knows experience.
OUP— Metaphysics-a conscious thinking subject;
Psychol. the
part of the mind that reacts to
reality and has a sense of individ-
uality: Psychol. the
part of the mind developed from
the ego by
an awareness of social standards.
[1780-90; < L: I; psychoanalytic term is trans. of G (das) Ich (the) I ]
'emotion'
versus 'feelings', Neff,
Britannica,
WikipediA, Bk.XIV:1:xxii,
Bk.XIV:2:180, Bk.III:241,
242.
°EMOTION,
Modification,
°JOY, BOREDOM, °SORROW,
I:Table 1, I:Table
2,
I:1.6, D:1.10ff,
I:2.5c, Calculus:Fig.1(a),
C:Fig.2,C:2.4,
C:Fig.3, I:2.5c,
E3:GenDef:185,
E4:XIV(1):198, E4:XLI:217,
E5:III:248, E5:XVII,
EL:[53]:xxvi,
EL:[56]:xxvii, EL:[57]:xxviii,
Mode. E3:General
Definition of the Emotions [Affects]:185,
Outlines
of Psychology.
E3:D.III:130—
]affectus
[, [Bk.VIII:46443
], >
Bk.III:241
<,
]affections[
Hampshire:135—affectus
"By emotionI
mean the modifications
of the body, whereby
E3:LeDoux96:43
the active
power of the said body {
to PERPETUATE
itself } is
Antonio Damasio
increased
or diminished, aided or constrained, and also the
MT:Damasio—James
ideas
{awareness}
of such modifications."
{ G:Note
1 & 2.
} Robinson3:15
{ Such
modification immanently causes
°DESIRE }
{ Scroll Down. }
{°EMOTION
is a change
in one's °Perpetuation.
The
answer.
Its intensity
is proportional to the change.
Biology
of Emotions—ANS
If
the change is negative, it is °SORROW.
If the
change is zero, it is BOREDOM.
E3:William James
If
the change is positive, it is °Joy.}
{ "°Emotion"
and "Intensity of emotion" are
equivalent terms because the symbol
°Emotion
implies an intensity, just as a triangle implies that its interior angles
are equal
to 180°. Calculus:Figs.3, 4,
5, & 6.
}
{
I:2.5c,
G:Shirley:2512—Waves,
C:Fig.2,
G:Notes 1 &2.
}
{ If the idea
of the change is based on "adequate knowledge",
E3:I:130
the idea is objective;
and the emotion is an active emotion.
E4:Dijn:247-
8
if not, the
idea is subjective; and the emotion
is a passive
E3:GN(2)n
emotion. }
Bk.XIV:2:1931,
Bk.VIII:46443,
Bk.III:241,
242
Shirley's Bk.VII:2821.
Emotion (affectus);
Usage by Spinoza explained—
< Bk.XV:277106—E3:DefEmo:173
>
This is the usual
translation of 'affectus,' and the translator
Hampshire:135—affectus
had best retain it
in default of a more accurate term. It cer-
tainly seems odd to speak of
'the emotions of desire' and this
is a sufficient
indication that 'affectus' is not quite the equiva-
lent of our
'emotion.' Its definition in Def. 3, III
makes it clear
that
'affectus' is equally a bodily state
(affectio) and its mental
LeDoux96:43
counterpart as idea,
but it is inevitable that Spinoza should be
more concerned with the latter
than the former.
<
Bk.XV:277106—E3:DefEmo:173
>
The names assigned
to the particular emotions
in Parts III and
IV will sometimes
appear strange to the reader. But Spinoza
emphasizes on more
than one occasion that he is not
analys-
ing the way
that words are used
in common
parlance. He
claims to deduce
emotion by strict
scientific reasoning from
his philosophic
position, and he assigns to these emotions
such names from common
usage as come nearest to express-
ing his meaning. Indeed,
some of the emotions thus deduced,
he says, have no names in common
language. This is in keep-
ing with his nominalism.
Words are not vitally important; they
are merely our way of getting
to the 'real.' {Cash
Value }
< From Endnote
1, Bk.XV:260—
. . . . One may compare
what
is done by scientists
when they introduce new technical
terms, or give old
words a new sense, with a view to explain-
ing what it
is that interests them. For Spinoza's views
on
definitions cf, TEI:[95-8]35.
>
RH— an affective state of consciousness
in which joy, sorrow,
LeDoux96:43
fear, etc., is experienced, as distinguished
from cognitive and
volitional states
of consciousness; a
strong agitation of the
Emotion
feelings caused by experiencing
{ Positive
values } joy,
happiness
passion, excitement, sentiment, zeal, ardor, fervor, heat,
warmth,
satisfaction, pride. {
Negative
values } concern,
agitation, anger,
jealousy, fear, sadness, despair,
vehemence, sorrow.
{ Note
how everyday language expresses the varying positive
and negative
intensities with another synonym.
G:Note
1 , I:1.6,
Calculus:Fig.1(a) }
[1570-80; to set in motion, move the feelings; agitation,
disturb-
ance of the mind, excite]
Neff,
WikipediA,,
Bk.VII:21:1,
Bk.XIV:1:xiii.
ESSENCE—Beingness(Essentia):
Nature, °PERPETUATION,
Includes,
E1:D.I:45. E2:D.II:82—Bk.XV:26957—E2:X(10)N2:89;
Bk.XIV:1:144, 145.
E3:VII:136—
]conatus[
"The endeavour,
wherewith everything endeavours to
Durant:638
persist in its ownbeing {
°P
} is nothing else but
the actual
essence of the thing
in question."
RH—the basic, real, and invariable nature of a thing;
substance;
(in philosophy) the true
nature or constitution of anything,
(opposed to) what is accidental,
phenomenal, illusory.
[1350-1400; to be]
Wikipedia
, Bk.XIV:1:xi, Bk.XIV:1:3.
Euclidean
Geometrical Method, EL:[35]:xxi,
Axiom, Calculus, I:1.3,
D:1.5a,
E3:Pfc(14):129, TTP1:V(66):76,
E1:Parkinson:2601,
Bk.III:154,188,189,1918,
Bk.XIB:245.
Bk.III:21129.
{ The subtitle
of the Ethics is "ordine geometrico demonstrata"
} Durant:636
EL:[3]:vi.—Geometrical
Method of "The Ethics".
Bk.XII:216;
Bk.XIV:1:32; 58.
Bk.XIX:20-22;Bk.XX:200.
Again, the form in which
his principal work is cast is such as
Runes:iii
to repel those dilettante readers, whose suffrage
is necessary
Einstein:i
for a widely-extended reputation; none but genuine
students
would care to grapple with
the serried array of definitions,
axioms, and propositions,
of which "The
Ethics",
{ Bk.I
}, is
composed, while the display
of geometric accuracy flatters
the careless into
supposing, that
the whole structure
is
interdependent,
and that, when a single breach
has been
effected, the entire fabric has been demolished.
Wolfson:1:581- Geometrical Method of "The Ethics".—
In a letter
to Oldenburg he says, "It is not my custom
to expose
the errors
of others,'' and in another
place he expresses a
reluctance "to
seem to be desirous of exposing
the errors of
others." In
still another place he declares himself not
to be
bound "to discuss what
every one may dream." By resorting
to
the use of the geometrical
form he could avoid all this, at least
openly.
But Spinoza never meant to imply that by his use of
the Wolf
geometrical form his philosophy,
like the geometry of Euclid, is
the unfoldment of
certain a priori
self-evident truths. For
his innate,
born-with
axioms,
properly understood, are not necessarily self-evident
truths, any more
than his propositions are
necessarily new
truths discovered by demonstration.
Most often they are merely
restatements
of generally accepted mediaeval
brocards.
{elementary
principles ^ }
RH— pertaining to Euclid, or adopting
his postulates: to claim or
assume the existence or
truth of, esp. as a basis for reasoning
or
arguing; to assume without proof, or as self-evident; Math.,
Logic. to
assume something taken as self-evident
or assumedwithout proof
as a basis for reasoning; Math., Logic. a proposition that
requires no
proof, being self-evident, or that is for
a specific purpose assumed
true, and that is used in the proof of other propositions;
axioms.
[1650-60; of Euclid]
[1525-35; postulate - petition, thing requested, to
request, demand]
Neff,
WikipediA
, Bk.XIV:1:xiii, xiv.
EXISTENCE,G–D,
No. 7, ETERNITY, E5:L29[4,
5](12):318,
E1:Def.I:45—
"By that which
is self-caused, I mean that
of which the
essence involves
existing,
or that of which the nature
is only conceivable as existent."
E1:Def.VIII:46—
"By eternity, I
mean existence itself, in so far as it is con-
ceived necessarily
to follow solely from the definition
of
that which is eternal."
Calculus:4.7
RH - the state or fact of existing; being;
all that exists:
Existence shows a universal order; entity.
OUP - the fact or condition of being or existing; all that exists.
[L exsistere , stare stand]
External,
ego, Id, Thing,
I:1.8, I:1.11,
E3:De.VI:175, E4:Axi:191,
Gas
{External includes yourself
as implied in the thought "I hate
myself." }
RH— of or pertaining to the world of things{including
the ego},
considered as independent of
the mind.
OUP— of or situated on the outside or visible part (opp.
internal);
coming or derived from the outside or an outside source;
outside
the conscious subject (the external world).
[outside]
WikipediA
°FAITH,
faith, °LOVE, INDIFFERENCE,
°HATE, I:Table 1,
Leap-of-faith, I:Table
3,
I:1.7, I:1.11, D:1.23, D:1.24, D:1.26b, D:1.28, TTP3:XIV(23):184, Bk.X:56,
CashValue, D2:Dijn:235, Grace, Free Will & Free Choice.
{°FAITH is
belief that an external
object will The
answer.
cause
a change
in one's °Perpetuation.
The intensity
is proportional to the
change.
Calculus
If
the change to be brought is negative, it is °HATE.
If
the change to be brought is zero, it is INDIFFERENCE.
If
the change to be brought is positive, it is °LOVE.}
The reason
for °FAITH is that you always need HOPES
(want that which you LOVE) and
{ Basis of
(negative °FAITH) always haveFEARS
(avoid that which you HATE).
Religion
}
G:Notes 1 &2,
I:Table 3,
D:1.23, D:1.26,
E3:XLVIII:161,
E3:L:162.
"This task I
hope to accomplish in the present chapter,
{ Separate
only for
and also to separate
Faith {scriptural
theology} from
philosophy,
analysis
and then
which is the chief aim of the whole
treatise."
synthesize.
}
{ For Spinoza, ultimate
°FAITH is religious "faith"—"FAITH",
not
capitalized.
TTP3:XIV(23,24):184,
TTP3:XIV(75):189.
G-D,
Loves G-D, Intellectual
love of G-D.}
RH— {Positive
values of FAITH}
confidence or trust in a person
Calculus:Fig.1(b)
or thing; belief that is
not based on proof:
belief, confidence, trust,
security, certitude, reliance, assurance,
certainty, credence, con-
viction, religion, creed, persuasion.
{Negative values - lack of FAITH} doubt,
uncertainty, skep-
ticism, dubiety; unbelief, disbelief;
mistrust, suspicion; misgiving,
apprehension, denial,
dissent, distrust, incredulity,
discredit,
infidelity, rejection, agnosticism.
{ Note how
everyday language expresses the
varying
intensities with another
word. G:Note 1, I:1.7,
D:1.26b. }
[1200-50; ME feith
< AF fed, OF feid, feit < L fidem, acc. of fides
trust, akin to
fidere to trust]
Fear,
Awe, TTP1:IV(34):60,
TTP1:IV(80):66, TTP1:IV(90):67
{ The Hebrew word translated as
fear is yir-aw', Strong:3374—
fear, reverence, holy, dreadful.
The root is yaw-ray', Strong:
3372—to
fear, to revere, to frighten. Based on this etymology,
the fear is like that of,
say, touching an active electrical wire,
fearing an undertow at the
beach, or passing a red light. The
{Bk.XIX:24831—
fear, or awe, stems
from knowing the consequences
of an act.
EL:L25(78):306}
The translation "to fear the Lord" is unfortunate; better would be "awe":
You are in awe
of an undertow and, if rational, would
not
put yourself in harms way by swimming
out into it.
You are in awe of G-D
and, if rational, would not cause your-
self a decrease
in °P by putting yourself
in harms way—
violating a Commandment.}
Fences,Parochial,
Hamshire:203b,
Nationhood, One
World,
Under conditions of scarcity, fences are necessary; but
under
conditions of affluence
as a result of technological advancement
they become superfluous.
RH—a barrier enclosing or bordering a field, yard, etc.,
usu.
made of posts and wire or wood, used to prevent entrance.
Neff,
Finite
I:1.4, definition,
idolatry, infinite, °RATIONAL,
I:1.5c , EL:[41]:xxiii,
Bk.XIV:1:133.
E1:Def.VII:46—
"That Thing {G-D} is called
free, which exists solely by the
Infinite
necessity
of its own nature,
and of which the action
is
Robinson5:40
determined by itself alone. On
the other hand, that thing {G-d}
finite
is necessary,
or rather constrained, which is determined by
MarkTwain
something external
to itself to a fixed and definite method of
existence
or action.
RH— having bounds or limits; measurable:
(of a set of mathe-
matical elements) capable of
being completely counted. not
zero. subject to limitations or
conditions, as of space, time,
circumstances, or the laws of nature. (opposed to)
infinite, unlimit-
ed, unbounded, boundless, measureless;
endless, perpetual.
[1375-1425; to stop, limit.]
Neff,
WikipediA , Bk.XIV:1:xvi,
xxii, Bk.XIV:2:164, Bk.III:246.
Free-will,
Volition,
Free Choice, Determinism,
Posit, Quibble,
EL:[55]:xxvii, EL:[55]:xxvii,
EL:L22ff(74):299,
Understanding,
Neff
L62(58):389,
Bk.XIII:276276—Neff
L60(56):389,
Bk.XV:276100,
Bk.XVII:167, Bk.XIV:2:164,
E2:Wolfson:2:178, Pineal
Gland, Durant65:177,
Circumstances,
Taylor/Wheeler92:iii,
Ripley:309.
EL:[48]:xxv— Man or G-D
We can, in
popular phrase, direct our thoughts at will,
MarkTwain
but the will,
which we speak of as spontaneous,
is really
TheComputerized
Machine.
determined
by laws as fixed
and necessary, as those
{The
same applies
which regulate the properties
of a triangle or
a circle.
to desire,
love, etc.}
<E5:Parkinson:283162>
, Bk.III:211.
William James's Bk.X:56— {CashValue, E2:Endnote 49:0.}
"Free-will thus has no meaning
unless it be
Britannica
a doctrine of relief . . ."
E2:XLIX(10):121— {EL:[52]:xxvi}
"Will and understanding are one and the same."
E2:Wolfson:2:1721,
2, & 3—Spinoza
now returns to his main problem, to show
that the will is not free, and with this also to deny the freedom
of
the other faculties, such as understanding,
desiring, loving, etc.,
all of which, like will, are only modes of thought.
RH— free and
independent choice; voluntary decision. the
WikipediA
doctrine that the conduct of human beings expresses
personal
choice and is not simply determined by physical or divine
forces.
Function,
Functionalism, Beauty,
Ugly, Pragmatic, Cash
Value, E4:Ap.30:242,
Dawkins:276—Brains
and Computers; Functionalism—Cartoon.
{Function
is an action which increases °P. Dysfunction is an
action
which decreases °P.
In preventing chaos, traffic-lights perform
the
same function as
heart valves. A dysfunctional traffic-light causes
chaos; a dysfunctional heart
valve causes . . . . }
RH— the kind of action or activity proper
to a person, thing, or
institution; the purpose for
which something is designed or
exists; role.
OUP— a mode of action or
activity by which a thing fulfills its
purpose; fulfill a function, operate; be in working order.
[1525-35; performance, execution]
Games,Conatus,
Escaped, Calculus:Fig.
2.
{ Games are atavistic
play-acting at an activity which in real life is
necessary for PERPETUATION.
Examples–sports, boxing, gambling,
{Controlled
war-games, fishing,
hunting, (some gunlovers are sublimating their
conatus}
aggressiveness). Sexual
intercourse without the desire to
have issue
is also a game.
Proof.– The more actual the
NEED; the more pleasurable,
the success;
the more sorrowful,
the failure.
Conspicuous and emulative consumption
are also games; because
Read "The
Theory
they are an attempt to show one better
than, or equal to, his fellow. }
of
the Leisure Class"
RH— an amusement or pastime; a competitive
activity involving skill,
chance, or endurance and played according
to a set of rules for the
amusement of the players or
spectators; a trick or strategy; wild
animals, including birds and fishes,
such as are hunted for food or
taken for sport or profit.
[bef. 1000; ME; OE gaman; c. OHG gaman glee]
Neff,
WikipediA,
Bk.XIV:1:xiv .
] that
is [
G–D
or DEUS,
ONE,
G-D, or Nature,
Nature, Being,
Religion, Idolatry,
Knowledge, Organic, Pragmatism, CashValue, Pantheism—G-d, Bk.X:56, Quibble
Works, I:1.5c, I:2.5c, D:2.2, TTP3:XIII(16):177, E1:Def. I-VIII:45, E1:XIV:54,
E5:XV:255, New Wine in Old Bottle—E1:Wolfson:1:158; D1:HirLev 19:18.
EL:[60]:xxix,LT:L36(23):345, Prejudice, Bk.XIB:246, 247—{ sham }.
Especially E1:Def.
VI:45—E1:Wolfson:1:158.
Bk.III:189—G:posit.
ST:Note 4, E5:Spinoza's
Daring.
"By G-D,
I mean a Being
absolutely
by hypothesis - ST:Note
4
infinite—that
is, a substance consisting
MOTIVE
in infinite attributes,
of which each ex-
presses eternal
and infinite essentiality"
G:Includes
{ and each
attribute has an infinite
Paraphrased by JBY
number of finite modes.
These modes
Added by JBY
are you, me, and every
other particular
EL:Endnote
Dijn:211.
thing; G-D
that is Nature
and G-d/nature.}
EL:Endnote
[37]Decartes.
{ G-D
at 100% °P
^ }
{ G-d
at <100% °P,
^ Disclaimer
}
G:Shirley:236—Spinoza's
Pantheism—G-d ^
Spinoza does not lower G-D to Nature, but
elevates Nature to G-D.
CashValue—an
all-inclusive organic interdependence of parts;
Robinson4:172
each part of which, though infinitesimal,
is significant.
Analogy—we
are parts of G-D as our body parts
are parts of us.
Deus, Posit,
EL:[40]:xxiii, TEI:[39,40]:14,
New wine in old
bottles.
I conjecture the reasons Spinoza continued to use the "language
of religion",
(G-D instead of Nature) are
the following:
1. The term
'G-D' is retained because
it is fulfilling the same
function
as the traditional God
(an evolving religion)—
Mark Twain
which is, to bring Peace-of-Mind.
It is the same as when
The God Gene
Judaism and Christianity evolved
and replaced Paganism,
Holidays
but still used the
term God.
2. 'G-D' adds,
importantly, the ingredient of Peace-of-Mind
which
'Nature' does not.
3. There is
great "vested
interest" in the word "G-D";
it is
Isaac
associated,
for many, with Peace-of-Mind.
Bashevis
Singer.
From Bk.VII:248—Sive
or Seu.
The orthodox translation
of these Latin words
is 'or.'
Spinoza nearly always
uses them to indicate an alternative
{The
terms
expression for what he is trying to say, and this in fact
gives us a
G-D
and Nature
valuable insight into the interlocking
of concepts that character-
are interchangeable.}
izes his system. But the English
'or' is frequently disjunctive; e.g.
you can travel by
this road or by that. So
the unvarying transla-
tion of
sive (seu) by 'or' can be quite
misleading.
I have therefore usually translated
it by 'that is' when it implies
E1:Endnote De. I
equivalence. When Spinoza uses 'hoc est,' which
he frequently
Hampshire:170
does, also translate as 'that is.'
TEI:[76:5]:29—
"... the sum total of being,
beyond which there is no being found."
Shirley's Bk.VII:235—G-D
(Deus), Divine,
Nature, Religion, Idolatry,
Organic, ST:Note
4,
Spinoza's Meaning, Spinoza's
Daring, Bk.III:190, 206,
211.
Although Spinoza gives
repeated warnings that his "Deus"
Old
Wine in New Bottles
{transcendent}
is far from the anthropomorphic
^
conception of God preva-
Einstein,
Hirsch
{Judaic-Christian-Islamic}
lent in the ^
theology
of his time, the reader will find it diffi-
cult to bear this constantly
in mind. It is not until E1:XIV:54,
Spinoza's
Daring
that G-D,
by definition {hypothesis},
is shown to be identical
{Whythis
with the infinite,
all-inclusive, unique substance,
and there-
hypothesis?}
after it is all too easy
to lose sight of this, as
the religious
overtones
of the word "God"
keep asserting themselves.
term
'G-D'
So Spinoza's frequent use
of the phrase "Deus sive Natura"—
{The terms G-D and Nature
G-D
that is Nature—is intended as a salutary
corrective.
are interchangeable.}
For Spinoza G-D
is all Being, all
Reality,
in all its aspects
and in all its infinite
richness. {
EL:[37]:xxii;
by intuition; Bk.XXI.
}
Isaac Bashevis
Singer
{ EL:L19(68):296,
EL:L20(71):297,
EL:L21(73):298,
EL:[60]:xxix, Prejudice.}
{ ONE,
TTP3:J---VAH,
Organic,
Posits.
}
Spinozistic meaning—D2:Dijn:235,
{ New
wine in old bottles—E1:Wolfson:1:158.
}
Bk.III:206;
Bk.XIB:230;
Bk.XX:24370.
{ A traditional,
anthropomorphic, transcendent
God can bring
Hampshire:202
immediate Peace-of-Mind
as does an infant's mother's breast.
Mark
Twain
This
is the source of
the enormous power of Mary for Catholics.
Nagel:274
(A picture
is worth a thousand abstractions.)
} James:129,
Hall:3:16.
Dawkins192:[5]
"I
believe in Spinoza's G-D
who reveals Himself in the
Bk.XXI
orderly harmony
of what exists, not
in a God who concerns
Hampshire:202
himself with fates
and actions of
human beings."
{ but
who concerns himself with objectivity—truth
or falsity;
Ferguson
not subjectivity—good
or bad. Calculus:4.4. }
Bk.XIB:246.
Einstein: Bx.XVI:38— "G-D does not play dice . . ."
. . . "G-D is subtle, but he
is not malicious." With
these words
he was to crystallize
his view that complex though the laws
of
nature
might be, difficult though they were to understand,
they
were yet
understandable by human reason. If a man worried
away at the law
behind the law—if, in Rutherford's
words, he
knew what questions to ask nature—then
the answers could
be discovered. G-D might
pose difficult problems but He
never broke the rules by posing unanswerable ones.
What is
more, He never left the answers to blind
chance—"G-D does
not play dice
with the world." {This
is written of Einstein; but could
as well apply to Spinoza.
}
See Secret:
{1D6=
ONE}
Importance
of 1D6 = ONE
{Spinoza goes
to great lengths
to posit
G–D—the
quintessential pragmatic
truth
(Cash
Value—an
all inclusive organic
interdependence and you
Heart
and lungs
can't harm one part
without eventually
harming yourself
or your The
Golden Rule
progeny.)
so as to
establish the foundation
for all
his thought.
Establishing the hypothesis
of G-D
Speculation
is the entire burden of the TEI
and Ethics-Part 1.}
ONE, Highest
Good, Quibble, Sham,
I:2.5b, I:2.11
, D:2.2 , D:2.10,
E2:X(12):90,
EL:[40]:xxiii, EL:[41]:xxiii,
TEI:[38:2]:14, TEI:[47]:17,
TEI:[70]:26,
TEI:[76:5]:29, TEI:[105]:38,
TTP1:4(24):59, D1:HirLev
19:18.
{ Bk.XIV:2:101—TEI:L64(60):395.
Example: POSIT—hypothesis,
dogma.
}
{G–D is
an hypothesis designed to improve the understanding.
I:2.1
, D:2.2 , E5:XXVII:261.
Understanding
increases peace-of-
mind.
E5:VI:250.
G–D (Religion)
is an hypothesis designed to
increase peace-of-mind.}
Bk.XIV:1:144, 145.
{I use the dash
in G–D, SH-DAI,and
J--VAH to
stress their ineffability
{ G-D
at 100% °P
-
and thereby not to
fall into idolatry—making
the infinite finite.
natura
naturata }
When a mode,
I use G–d with a small 'd' (not
consistently).
{ G-d
at <100% °P
-
TTP3:XIII(16):177,
HirPent:Ex 20:4, Pantheism—G-d.
natura naturata
}
Also,
in accord with Jewish taboo, the Name
is not written
on a medium that might be trashed;
this would be like disposing of
your national flag
in the garbage. The Scrolls in the synagogue
and other Sacred texts that
do print the
Name are given a human-
type burial when
no longer fit for use. In speaking, the circumlo-
cution used is "ha-Shem",
Strong:8034(2)—the
NAME."}
Bk.XIV:1:144-5.
RH— the creator and ruler of the universe;
Supreme Being;
any deified person or object; Christian Science. the Supreme
Being
considered with reference to the sum of His attributes.
OUP— make perpetual; preserve from oblivion.
WikipediA.
Golden Rule+1+2,
Categorical
imperative, Enlightened self-interest,
Altruism,
Evolutionary
ethics, Natural
law, Confucianism,
Organic, Important,
Essay:5.
D:Endnote 1.27d—From HirPent: Lev 19:18
"....but
thou shalt love thy neighbour's
HirPent:Gn
43:14
well-being as t'were
thine own: I am G-D."
Following the Golden
Rule is in your own self-interest;
it is not altruism;
Mark
Twain
it is biological
necessity—the law of organic
interdependence. The lung
must love the heart's well-being
and vice versa.
The rule becomes more and more complied
with as a society becomes Hampshire:179[1a]
more and more technologically
advanced and affluent (less
scarcity).
Marginal Value
Neff
Neff
Good and Bad,
E1:(AP:47, 52):79,
E3:IX(5):137, E4:(Prf:2):187,
E4:(Prf:32):189,
E4:Def.I:190,
E4:XIX:202, E4:LXV:231,
E4:LXVIII:232, TEI:[12:2]:6,
Mark
Twain,
TEI:[13:2]:6, TTP4:XVI(21):202,
EL:[45]:xxv, EL:[55]:xxvii,
EL:[57]:xxviii, Evil
(Satan).
E4:(Prf:27):189—E1:Shirley:609;Bk.XIB:251;Bk.XX:188.
{ likewise perfect and
imperfect }
Ferguson
"As for the
terms good and bad, they indicate no positive
Prof.
Hall:79
quality in
things regarded in themselves,
but are merely Robinson3:15
modes of thinking,
or notions which we form from
the
LT:3219:331
comparison of things
one with another. Thus one
and
LT:L3421:336
the same thing
can be at the same
time good, bad, and
Calculus:Fig.1(b),
indifferent. ...."
{scroll
down for more }
Bk.XIA:12939;Bk.XII:325
.
{
good/bad; perfect/imperfect }
E4:Dijn:34,
247
Nevertheless, though this
be so, the terms should
still E4:Parkinson:280136
be retained.
For, inasmuch as we desire
to form an idea
of man
as a type of human nature which
we may hold in
Hampshire:145
view {as a
model},
it will be
useful for us to retain the terms
E4:Dijn:247-
8
in question, in the sense I have
indicated {subjectively,
from the point-of-view of the
survival of the species 'man'}.
Bk.XIB:5238,
Subjective.
E3:IX(5):137—
It is thus plain from what has been said, that in no case
do we
strive for, wish for, long
for, or desire anything, because we
False
goods—gods
deem it to be good, but on
the other hand we deem a thing
to be good, because we
strive for it,
wish for it, long for it,
or desire it.
{A man, when rational
and judging correctly, calls a thing
good
Good
and Evil
if it increases his °P—bad;
otherwise} E4:Def.I:190
Bk.XIB:111.
{When a little fish
is eaten by a bigger fish, does not
the little fish
Naturalistic
view
"think" that's
bad and does
not the bigger fish
"think" that's
good (because each one seeks
to preserve itself)?" We
say that is
Nature,
the food chain; if the cycle stops,
all life stops. However,
We—species
'Man'
we
are like that little fish—or, like that big fish; abused or
abuser.
Good
and bad are subjective terms;
things just 'are'—the chain of
causes.
Talk of good and evil is, objectively, meaningless.
When Adam
and Eve started
to think in terms of "good and bad",
Mark
Twain
i.e. subjectively;
instead of "true and false",
i.e. objectively; they
Ferguson
self-thrust themselves
from the Garden
of Eden,
i.e. they were
Calculus:6.2b &
c.
subject to loss
of °PcM.
LT:L32(19):331,
E5:VI:250, E3:GN2n,
E1:Shirley:609.
}
Bk.XIB:250—EL:xi:1.
°HATE,
I:Table 1, I:Table
3, °LOVE, I:1.7,
I:1.13, D:1.31,
I:2.5c,
E3:XIII(3):140, E3:De.VI:175,E5:XVIIc:256.
E3:De.VII:176—
{°HATE
is belief that an external
object will
needs
decrease
one's °Perpetuation.
The intensity
is proportional to
the decrease feared.
If
the decrease is negative (an increase), it is °LOVE.
If
the decrease is zero, it is INDIFFERENCE.
If
the decrease is positive, it is °HATE.}
E3:XLIII:159—
Hatred is increased by being reciprocated,
and can on the
other hand be destroyed
by love. {
E3:XLIV:159,
Pity
}
E4:XLV:218—
"Hatred can never be good." E2:XLIX(69):126.
{The definition of
Pity implies a mother-type forgiveness
because everything is bound
into an organic interdepend-
ence. Not
to forgive would be like cutting-off your nose
Sin
to spite your face.}
TTP4:XVI(107):211,
Neff EL:L25(78):305.
RH— { Negative
values of °FAITH
} to dislike intensely
or passion-
ately; feel extreme aversion for
or extreme hostility toward;
detest; the object of
extreme aversion or hostility: dislike,
despise, detest, abhor, loathe, abominate,
execrate, hold in
contempt, bear malice toward, be
hostile to, have no use for,
recoil from, shrink from, be
repelled by. { Note
how everyday
Calculus:Fig.1(b)
language expresses varying
intensity with another word.
G:Note 1,I:1.7,D:1.26b.
}
Highest Good,
Blessedness, E4:XXXVI(36:2n):211,
E4:Ap.IV:237,
E4:Ap.XXV:240,
TEI:[12]:6, TEI:[25:IV]:10,
TTP1:IV(25-37):59,
Neff.
The mind's highest good is
the knowledge of G-D,
and the
E4:Dijn:247
mind's highest {moral}
virtue is
to know G-D. {
WHY?
}
Letter:3724[7]:171.
From Parkinson's Introduction to Bk.XV:xx-xxii—Spinoza's Religion:
Religion, as he understands
it, is 'Whatever we desire and do of which we are the
cause, in so far
as we ... know G-D' {so
that we can have peace-of-mind}
(4P37n1). To
grasp the full meaning of this,
one must take account of the fact that there is for
Spinoza a link between one's
knowledge of G-D and one's activity as a moral
agent
{to
act as a part of an infinite organism
so that, that organism can be healthier and you, as part of that
organism, be healthier.}. This
link involves what is page
xxi perhaps the key concept
of Spinoza's moral philosophy,
namely, the concept of freedom {the
heart acts freely in
accordance with its nature, the lung
acts feely in accordance with its nature, for the health of the
organism.}.
There is a more
direct link between religion and morals.
If religion is an hypothesis
designed to find peace-of-mind, as I think it is, whose life is more
peaceful and tranquil, an honest man or a thief—certainly
the honest man. If a thief is a
pious person, his religion is not religion but idolatry—he
is asking his idol {thievery}
to bring him good fortune in
his thievery.
WikipediA,
Holy, Rational,
Sacred, Worship, Revelation,
Isaiah 6:3.
{The Hebrew word for Holy is ko'desh,
Strong:6944—a
sacred
place or thing,
hallowed, holiness. The root
of ko'desh is
kaw-dash' , Strong:
6942—to be pure, clean, i.e. right, straight,
true, just. Based on
this etymology, what is pure, clean, right,
straight, true,
just, etc., is Holy; the
test is—that which
PERPETUATES
is Holy. If it does not PERPETUATE,
it is
unholy—profane.}
RH— recognized as or declared
sacred by religious use or
authority; dedicated or devoted
to the service of God, the
church, or religion; saintly; pious;
devout; having a spiritually
pure quality: a holy
love; inspiring fear, awe, or distress.
[bef. 900; WHOLE = a
thing complete in itself or comprising all
Worm
its parts or elements.]
{Mysticism}
WkipediA,
Britannica
Hypothesis,
posit, axiom, dogma,
knowledge, ONE, pragmatic,
truth, Pagan,
I:2.1, D:2.5d,
D:2.6,
D:2.6d, D:2.11,
Cash Value , BkX:56,
TTP2:Note 8,
TEI:[62]:23, Infinite,
Induction,
Deduction, Intuition, Scientific
Method,
Religion,Belief,
Leap
of Faith, Determinism.
OUP—Posit: a statement which is made on the assumption that it will prove valid.
RH— a provisional theory set forth
to explain some class of
phenomena, either accepted
as a guide to future investigation
(working
hypothesis) or assumed for the
sake of argument
ST:Note
4
and testing; a proposition assumed as a premise
in an argument.
[1590-1600; basis, supposition, to assume, suppose]
OUP— a proposition made as a basis for reasoning,
without the
assumption of its truth; supposition made as a starting-point
for
further investigation from known facts (cf. theory).
[Etymology foundation (as hypo-, thesis)]
{An hypothesis is subject to error.
Care must be taken to follow
the scientific
method—a method of research in which a problem
is identified, relevant data
gathered, a hypothesis is formulated,
and the hypothesis is empirically
tested.
An hypothesis
is an unproven, but as yet uncontradicted
opinion. The truth
of an hypothesis (or speculation) is in pro-
portion to its usefulness
in increasing °P.} Quibble,
Cash Value.
Hypothesis, like hope,
always involves doubt and constant
evolution
as it proves and disproves itself.
Definitions
which attempt to define things by their causes
1P1
are really hypotheses;
they need to be constantly updated
as knowledge evolves; likewise,
Spinoza's Propositions are
hypotheses.
To think otherwise is to fall into
idolatry—
making the infinite
finite.
Religion
WikipediA,
Id,
external, ego, E3:Def.II:129.
RH— Psychoanal, the part of the
psyche that is the source of
unconscious and instinctive
impulses that seek satisfaction in
accordance with the pleasure principle.
Mark Twain
OUP— Psychol. the inherited instinctive impulses of the
individ-
ual as part of the unconscious.
[1924; < L id it, as a trans. of G Es lit., it]
Neff,
Bk.XIV:1:xxi-3.
Idea, Adequate,
Confused, Perception,
E2:Def.III:82,
E2:XLIX:120, E2:XLIX(13):121.
E2:XLVIII(11):120—
For by ideas
I do not mean images such as are
formed at E1:Parkinson:26311—True
Idea
the back
of the eye, or in the midst of the brain, but the
Hampshire:99-100
^
conceptions
of thought.
Shirley's Bk.VII:2513—Idea. TEI:[38]:14, E2:XLVIII(8) & XLIX:120, E1:XXX:(1):69, common notion.
This an extremely important term in Spinoza's
philosophy.
It is not usually equivalent to the English
"idea," when the
Hampshire:135—affectus
latter is synonymous with "notion" or image."
In fact, Spin-
oza warns us not to construe "idea"
as signifying a pictor-
ial representation of a thing,
a "dumb picture
on a tablet."
E2:Parkinson:27484
An idea, for Spinoza is an
act of thought; it is almost a
2P49—example
transitive verb having an object,
its ideate (‘ideatum"),
i.e. "that which is idea-ed."
Spinoza does in fact use
"objectum" ("object")
and "ideatum" ("ideate") as alternative
Bombardi
expressions. <
^ Bk.XV:27059on
E2:D.IV:82 >
{ LT:L66(64):398
}, ] E1:Shirley:609
[
In many contexts the term
"idea" has the meaning
of
judgment, or
assertion (E2:XLVIII(4), XLIX).
Accordingly,
"idea" is for Spinoza
closer in signification to the term
Hypotheses
"proposition"
than to such terms as "concept" or "notion."
Definition
Ideas will then be true
or false { subject to intense scrutiny }.
{ Example.—The
quintessential (pragmatic) "idea" is
Spinoza's posit of G-D,
a true
idea. }
Neff,
WikipediA,
Idolatry,
Profane, G-D, Noachide
Laws, Three injunctions,
Superstition+1,
Pagan,
Religion,
Nationalism, Perverted
Pantheism, Pragmatism, Quibble,
Dogma+1.
Idolatry is taking the infinite
as finite.
Spinozistic
Idea
Taking the finite as infinite is pantheism.
Definition
Idolatry (defining
the finite) is taking an
inseparable part of an
infinite
organism (G-D)
as finite—and having it (the part, a mode)
stand
alone finite and supreme without
interaction with the other parts;
breaking down the
organic interdependence of parts. (Money,
Robinson3:189
slums, sex, substance
abuse, etc.)
A part may be separated for analysis, study, and improvement
purposes; much as a heart doctor studies the heart;
but he is
always conscious of the interaction of the
heart with the rest of
the body.
Idolatry is not an 'I-thee'
relation with a thing; but an 'I-It'
relation.
Pantheism—G-d
Idolatry and superstition
are faulty hypotheses designed to find
peace of mind. The fault
is in making the infinite finite.
Idolizing
a part, ignoring the whole;
idolizing money, a golden calf
LeDoux96:129
(Exo.
32:4), farmers who pollute, substance abuse, creating
slums,
Sin, Nagel:274.
rampant
capitalism, any fixation to the exclusion
of other things
Buber's 'I-It'
leads to chaos.
Idolatry
is taking something that cannot stand
alone and making it
stand alone to the detriment of other things
(which includes even God).
HirPent:Ex 20:4 - The ThirdCommandment. WikipediA.
"Thou shalt not make unto thee
any graven image, or any
{The
sins of
likeness of any thing that is in heaven
above, or that is in
the fathers }
the earth beneath, or that is in the
water under the earth, ...."
{It is natural that idolatry
of images should occur because infinity is
expressible only
by a symbol; but the symbol should not stand
for a deity or a
State. They should be symbols of an idea or ideal.
Except for the
National Flag
which represents the State (pity),
Jewish symbols generally represent:
1. Law— the Torah;
Talmud;
Constitution, din
medinah din.
2. Learning—the Menorah
(a candelabrum used in modern
synagogues);
the light of knowledge—burning midnight oil.
3. Love
of G-D—the Mezuzah;
( a parchment scroll, inscribed
with
Deu. 6: 4-9
and 11:
13-21, inserted in a case and
attached to an exterior
doorpost of the home. Some
have
the word Sh-dai
inscribed on the outside of
the case.
In effect "posit"
(Deu. 6:4—the Shema)
and "meditation"
(Deu. 6:7) are encapsulated. It is meant, ideally,
to be a
reminder of "Right
Way ofLiving"
as you enter and leave
the home.
From "Shema" Encyclopædia Britannica Online:
The Shema texts are
also chanted at other times during
the Jewish liturgy. The
biblical verses inculcate the duty
to learn, to study, and to observe
the Torah. These texts
Torah
and their appropriate
prayers are consequently sacred
to Jews
because they contain a profession
of faith,
a declaration of
allegiance to the kingship and kingdom
of G-D, and a symbolic representation
of total devotion to
the study of the Torah.
{4.
Nationhood—the Star
of David; Nationalism. This
symbol
is
not Spinozistic. It becomes a divisive symbol
(fence)
{A Menorah
is a
like the Cross,
Crescent, and National flags. National
flags more
proper symbol}
should
become to the United Nations what the U.S. State
flags
are to the United States of America.
From The Quotable Einstein; 0691026963; 1996; Page 98:
My awareness of the essential
nature of Judaism resists the idea of a Jewish state with
borders, an army, and a measure of temporal power. . . . I
am afraid of the inner damage Judaism will sustain—especially
from the development of a narrow nationalism within our ranks,which we
have already had to fight strongly even without a Jewish state....
A return to a nation in the political sense of the word would
be equivalent to turning away from the spiritualization
of our community which we owe to the geniusof our prophets.
New York Times, June 8, 1936
Ideally
this is so; but what were the Jews to do after German Nazism.
March into the sea.
As a result the Jews and the Arabs suffer.}
From The Quotable Einstein; Page 241:
He was a Zionist on general humanitarian
grounds rather than on nationalistic grounds. He felt
that Zionism was the only way in which the Jewish problem in Europe could
be settled.... He was never in favor of aggressive
nationalism, but he felt that a Jewish homeland in
Palestine was essential to save the remaining Jews in Europe....After the
State of Israel was established, he said that some- how he felt happy he
was not there to be involved in the deviations from
the high moral tone he detected.
Ernst Straus, quoted in Whitrow, Einstein, pp. 87-88
{The
Pantheon of deified figures of modern
world religions is
an evolution
of the Pantheon of Pagan gods.
This is not pejorative (derogatory)
of either Pantheon. It
is the evolution of the hypothesis of Religion
Holidays
to purer and purer
Monotheism—from the fetish of
a caveman to
an unadulterated
Monotheism.}
RH— an image or other material object representing a deity
and
worshiped as such; (in the
Bible) a deity other than God; a
person or thing devotedly or excessively admired;
a mere image
or semblance of something, visible
but without substance; a
false notion; fallacy. excessive admiration or devotion;
inordinate
love, worship, adoration, obsession,
preoccupation, excessive
fondness, passion, devotion, veneration, single-minded attention,
infatuation, senseless attachment, madness, mania.
OUP— an image of a deity
etc. used as an object of worship;
Bibl. a false god; a person or thing
that is the object of excessive
or supreme adulation.
[1200-50; ME < LL idolum < Gk eídolon image,
idol, der. of
eîdos shape, form (see eidetic)]
INDIFFERENCE,I:Table
3, I:1.7b, I:1.13A,
D:1.36d, D:1.37
{ INDIFFERENCE is
belief that an external
object
will not change °Perpetuation. G:Notes
1 &2.
It marks the theoretical
transition
from °LOVE to °HATE and
vice versa.
Calculus:Fig. 2. }
RH— lack of interest, unimportance, little
or no concern.
Calculus:Fig.(b)
{ Note
that the synonyms for INDIFFERENCE, unlike
those for °LOVE
and °HATE, do not essentially
indicate any difference in degree.
°FAITH
= 0, I:Table 3, I:1.7b.
}
Wikipedia,
Induction,
I:2.1, Compare DEDUCTION—Peter
Berger.
TEI:[19:4]:8—No. III.
"Perception arising
when the essence {
the general
}
of one thing
is inferred from another thing {
the
particular },
but { possibly
} not adequately;
this comes . . ."
{ I:2.6A
}
RH— (in logic). any form of reasoning in which
the conclusion,
though supported by the premises,
does not follow from them
necessarily; the process
of estimating the validity of observa-
tions of part of a class of
facts as evidence for a proposition
about the whole class; a conclusion
reached by this process.
{
à
posteriori
}
OUP— the inference of a general law from particular
instances.
Neff,
WikipediA,
Bk.XIV:1:xiii .
Infinite,
G-D only is
infinite, finite, idolatry,
°RATIONAL, I:1.4,TEI:[89]:33,
Sham ,
Neff—E5:L29(12):317—Spinoza's
famous letter on the Infinite,
Indivisible,
Bk.XIV:1:133.
E1:Def.VII:46—
{always}
"That Thing
{G-D}
is called ^ free, which exists solely by the
necessity of its own Nature
{to
be},
and of which the action
Infinite
is determined by
itself alone. On the other hand,
that Robinson5:40
thing {G-d}
is necessary, or rather constrained,
which is de-
MarkTwain
termined by something
external to itself to a
fixed and
Finite
definite method
of existence or action.
{With
our present state of knowledge we do
not comprehend
Disclaimer
concepts
which involve infinity ( G-D
); we can only hypothesize
and test the hypothesis
on the basis of its Cash
Value.}
RH— unbounded or unlimited; boundless;
endless. (opposed
to) small, little, limited; finite;
circumscribed, definitive, restricted,
limited, bounded, measurable.
OUP— Math. a greater than any assignable quantity
or count-
able number; of a series)
that may be continued indefinitely.
[1350-1400; boundless.]
WikipediA,
Insight,
I:1.2a, Intuition,
Revelation & Prophecy, Spinoza,
Awareness, Artistic
Import, CashValue
{ Examples— I:1:7c, Calculus:1:4 }
RH— an instance of apprehending the
true nature of a thing,
esp. through intuitive understanding;
penetrating mental vision
or discernment: perception, spontaneous understanding, appre-
hension, acumen, innate knowledge, penetration,
discernment,
intuition, penetrating judgment, immediate, cognition,
perspica-
city, perspicaciousness, perceptiveness, perceptivity, instinctive
knowledge, clear understanding, comprehension.
{ antonyms
} obtuseness, blindness.
OUP— the capacity of understanding
hidden truths etc., esp. of
character or situations.
[discernment, in - sight]
Neff,
Bk.XIV:1:xxv.
Intellectual Love
of G-D, Love of G-D,
Mysticism, Awareness,
Organic, TEI:[10]:5,
E5:XXXII(2):263,
E5:XXXIII:263, E5:XXXV:264,
E5:XXXVI:264, E5:XXXVII:266,
Love, TTP1:IV(25-37):59,
EL:[60]:xxix, EL:Endnote
xxix:1A, CashValue,
Einstein, Buber:127,
{The intellectual
awareness of the organic
interdependence of all parts of the ONE
is what Spinozism calls the enlightening
Intellectual Love of G-D.}
EL:[59]:xxviii— < E5:Parkinson:284173, 285177 >; Bk.XII:286; Bk.XIV:2:302, 2:3084; Bk.XIB:251.
While we contemplate
the world as a necessary result of
the perfect
Nature of G-D,
a feeling of joy will arise in our
better,
a feeling of °PcM
hearts, accompanied by the idea
of G-D as its cause.
cosmic
religious feeling
This is the intellectual
love of G-D, which is the highest
Isaac
Bashevis Singer
happiness {
better,
°PcM
} man can know. { LT:L34(21):336}
{Cosmic
religious feeling—E5:Dijn:258;
Theistic and
Non-theistic world views synthesized}
E5:XXXII(2)c:263—
From the third
kind of knowledge necessarily
arises the
intellectual love of G-D. From this kind of
knowledge arises
pleasure accompanied
by the idea of G-D as cause, that is
(Def. of the Emotions:vi.),
the love of G-D; not in so far as
we imagine him as
present (V:xxix.),
but in so far as we
understand
him to be eternal;
this is what
I call the
intellectual love of
G-D.
Neff,
WikipediA,
Intuition,
Insight, Revelation,
Mysticism, Artistic
Import, I:2.1, D:2.5d,
TTP2:VII(170):116,
E4:Ap.IV:237, E5:XXXVI(8):265,
Power
of Intuition, Bk.XIV:2:155.
Intuition is designing
an hypothesis.
Electricity
Intuition is the knowledge
that comes from
a mystical experience.
.
TEI:[19:5]:8— < E5:Parkinson:285177 >
" . . the perception arising
when a thing is Robinson3:170
perceived
solely through its essence, or
Intuition
is the 'aha' moment.
through the
knowledge of its
proximate
cause."
E2:XL(19):113.
{Understanding}
{ a priori,
innate, born-with.
}
Wolf:P15,
L5
RH— direct perception of truth,
fact, etc., independent of any Encyclopædia
Britannica
{ conscious
} reasoning process;
immediate apprehension; a fact,
truth, etc., perceived in this way; the
qualityor ability of having
such direct perception or quick insight. I:2.7
OUP— immediate apprehension by the mind without reasoning;
immediate apprehension by a sense; immediate insight.
[1400-50; the act of gazing at; look; contemplate; watch over]
WikipediA,
'emotion' versus 'feelings'
°JOY,
I:Table 1, °PLEASURE,I:Table
2, Introduction, I:1.6,
I:1.9, D:1.13,
D:1.13N,
D:1.18ff,
E3:XI(2):138,
E3:De.III(1):174, E3:De.V:175,TEI:[109]:40,
Happy.
E3:De.II:174—
"Pleasure{
°JOY,
happiness }
is the transition of a man from a less
1AP:53
to a greater perfection,
{ °
P }. E5:Deleuze:130a.
Calculus
{°JOY
is an increase
in °Perpetuation.
E4:XLVII(3):220
Its intensity
is proportional to
the increase.
Calculus
If
the increase is negative, it is °SORROW.
If
the increase is zero, it is BOREDOM.
If
the increase is positive, it is °JOY.}
E4:Damasio
This definition holds for a RATIONAL person; not for an irrational person.
I:2.5c, Bk.VII:2512
, G:Notes
1 &2.
It is not the attainment, it is the
attaining—for attainment soon
turns to boredom
and then sorrow. Waves,
D:I.21c.
RH— { Positive
values of °EMOTION
} a feeling or state of
great
delight or happiness; as caused
by something exceptionally
good or satisfying. delight,
happiness, gladness, exultation,
satisfaction, rapture,
fullness of heart, ecstasy, elation, excite-
ment, cheerfulness, glee,
gaiety, exhilaration, delectation,
jubilation, enjoyment, pleasure, contentment. {
Note how everyday
language expresses varying intensity
with another word. G:Note 1, I:1.6,
D:1.26b.}
Calculus:Fig.1(a)
[rejoice]
WikipediA,
Bk.XIV:1:xxi, Reality
Curve.
Knowledge,
I:2.1, D:2.2,
E1:Shirley:609,E4:Dijn:247-
8, E4:XXVIII:205,
E5:XXV:260,
E5:XXVIII:261, E5:XXXIII:263,
E5:XXXVI(8):265, TEI:[19]:8,
Bk.III:51-58,
EL:[34]:xxi,
EL:[51]:xxvi, EL:[60]:xxix,
Imagination,
Reason, Intuition.
From Terry
Neff's Topic
Index:
Three kinds in the Ethics, E2:XL(19n2):113:
Four kinds in TEI:[19]:8. I:2.1
Knowledge
of the First
kind (Imagination or Opinion) TEI:[19:2],
Bk.III:51, Bk.VII:2720.
Raw, unverified
data (conceptions). E2:XL(21)n2:113.
Knowledge of the Second
kind (Reason)
TEI:[19:3&4] , Bk.III:52-56.
E2:Wolfson:2:1623
Verified
data, but subject to error.
E2:XL(23)n2:113.
Durant:647
< E5:Parkinson:285177
>
Knowledge of the Third
kind (Intuition) TEI:[19:5]
, Bk.III:57-58, E5:XXV:260.
Fourth
Number
Knowing
G-D, not subject to error.
E2:XL(24)n2:113.
{ ^
the knowledge that comes from a mystical
experience.}
G-D
"knows" and what G-D "knows" is knowable; example—double
helix.
The 'cash value'
of this hypothesis is 'keep studying'.
{Studying "knowledge"
leads to understand-
ing
the purpose of
Spinoza's hypothesis
of
G–D;
the hypothesis (posit) becomes
the
a
priori {innate, born-with} axiom
on which all his
Wolf:P15,
L5
definitions
and hypotheses rest. 1D6=
ONE
Importance of 1D6
= ONE
Studying adequate
knowledge inculcates the
Encyclopædia
Britannica
objective
thinking which leads to PcM.
E3:GN(2)n
, TEI:[16]:7
}
"I have made a ceaseless
effort not to ridicule,
not to bewail,
not to scorn human actions,
but to understand
them."
RH— acquaintance with facts, truths,
or principles; general
erudition; familiarity or conversance, as by study
or experience;
the fact or state of knowing; clear and certain mental
apprehen-
sion; the body of truths or
facts accumulated in the course of
time; the sum of what is known:
Knowledge of the situation is
limited.
OUP— Philos. true,
justified belief; certain understanding,
as
opp. to opinion.
[1250-1300; KNOW]
WikipediA,
Reality Curve
°LOVE,
°HATE, Charity,
I:Table 3, Altruism,
Introduction, ONE, Pity,
I:1.7, I:1.13,
D:1.28b, D:1.33ff,
E3:XIII(3)n:140, E4:XLIV:218,
E4:Ap.XIX:240, E5:XVIIc:256,
TEI:[9]:5, TEI:[109]:40,
Loves G-D , D1:HirLev
19:18, Bk.XIB:22175.
E3:De.VI:175—
"Love is pleasure [JOY]
accompanied by the
idea {awareness}
Free
Will
of an external cause."
{ mysticism
}
{ °LOVE
is belief that an external
object will
Need
increase
one's °Perpetuation.
The intensity is
Calculus:6.2b
& c
proportional to the
increase hoped for.
E4:XLVII(3):220
If
the increase is negative (a decrease), it is °HATE.
If
the increase is zero, it is INDIFFERENCE.
Calculus
If
the increase is positive, it is °LOVE.}
G:Notes 1 &2,
Immanent, D:1.34a,
I:2.5c, E3:XVIII(8):143,
E3:XLVIII:161.
{One of the main
purposes of Spinoza's
"Ethics" is
to teach that you do not
LOVE Mark
Twain
altruistically,
but out of self-interest.
If the
An unfaced
truth.
LOVE be rational
it leads to an increase in
°P
for both the lover
and that loved; if not
Martin
Buber
rational, a decrease.} Love
of G-D, Deut 6:4-15. I:2.7d
Substitute the word 'need'
for 'love' and you will understand 'love'
in its full dimensions. There is no
'altruism'.
Mark Twain
{ Yiddish expresses the above
beautifully by saying on leaving
"be for me (i.e. my sake),
well." In the analogy
it would be like
the lung saying
to the heart "be well for my sake," knowing
full-well that it
must in turn, send well-oxygenated blood to
the
Power of Love.
heart.
This is what I mean by "organic interdependence".}
RH— { Positive
values of °FAITH
} a profoundly
tender, passionate
Calculus:Fig.1(b)
affection for another person; a person
toward whom { or
a thing
toward which
} love is felt; to need
or require: Plants love sunlight.
passion, ardor, infatuation; devotion,
adoration, fondness, ten-
derness, affection, warm feeling,
sentiment, emotion, esteem,
admiration; friendship, amity,
brotherhood, affinity, sympathy,
concord, congeniality, cordiality; charity,
goodwill, benevolence,
solicitude. { Note
how everyday language expresses varying intensity
with
another word.
G:Note 1,D:1.26b.
}
OUP— (love-hate relationship),
{ everyday language
D:1.26b },
an intensely emotional relationship
in which one or each party
has ambivalent feelings of love and hate for the other.
[to be pleasing]
Bk.XIV:1:xxv. Bk.XII:286;
Bk.XVIII:345;Bk.XX:189.
LOVE of G-D,
Intellectual Love of G-D, Pragmatism,
Mysticism, Altruism,
EL:[40]:xxii,
EL:[59]:xxviii,
TTP3:XII(61):172,
E5:XVI:255, E5:XX(1):256,
E5:XXXVI:264,
E5:XXXVI(6):265,
Cash Value,
D1:HirLev 19:18, HirPent:
Gn 43:14. Bk.XIB:252155.
E5:XV(1):255—
He who clearly and distinctly
understands himself and
his
{
The terms
emotions loves G-D
{knows
G-D WHY?},
and so much the more in
G-D
and Nature
proportion as he more understands himself and his emotions.
are interchangeable.
}
From E5:Pollock:2801—
.... the love of G-D—which
is nothing else than the rational
Bk.XX:190--Love
of G-D
contemplation of
the order of the world, and of human
nature
E5:Wolfson:2:311
as a part thereof—....{Realizing
that everything is organically interdependent.}
Hampshire:170
{"Love
G-D" says "be aware
that you NEED G-D—everything,
conceived as a Unity—for
your very own PERPETUATION".
LT:L34(21):336.
Nutshell. TTP1:III(12):44.
"G-D love you" (or "G-D bless you," which is the same) says: Metaphors
1. May everyone
and everything contribute to your
perpetuation.
2. May everyone
be aware that they need
you for their
perpetuation—and
may you be worthy of such need.
"Thank G-D" (or "Please G-D," which is almost the same) says: Help of G-D
1. May everyone and
everything cause the thing to happen.
2. May everyone
be aware that they need
you for their
thing
to happen—and may you be worthy of such need.
Cash Value—an all-inclusive organic interdependence. Analogy }
WikipediA.
Marginal Value,
Reality Curve, Intensity
of emotion, Cash Value, Affluent.
pg. 140.
The doctrine of diminishing
marginal utility,
as it was
Calculus:4.3a
enshrined in the
economics textbooks, seemed to
put economic ideas squarely
on the side of the
diminishing importance of production
under condi-
tions of increasing affluence.
With increasing
per
capita real income, men
are able to satisfy additional
wants. These are of a lower order of urgency.
This
being so, the production that provide
the goods that
satisfy these less urgent
wants must also be of
smaller (and declining) importance.
RH—1.
pertaining to a margin. 2. situated on a border, edge, or
fringe. 3. at the lower limits;
minimal for requirements: marginal
ability. 4. written or printed
in the margin of a page. 5. insignifi-
cant; minor: a marginal improvement.
6. having contact with two
or more cultural
groups but not fully accepted in any of them.
7. a. selling goods at a price that
just equals the additional cost
of producing the last unit
supplied. b. of or pertaining to goods
produced and marketed at margin: marginal
profits.
[1570-80; < ML marginalis]
Neff,
Bk.VII:23:6,Bk.XIV:1:xii,
xv, xviii; Reality
Curve
Mode,
Shirley:2821,
EL:[43, 46]:xxiv,
E1:XV(1):55, E1:XXIII:65,
E2:VI:86, Bk.VIII:94[3],
Neff
- E5:L29[5](12):318,
Infinite Modes—Bk.XII:187,
Bk.XIV:1:224,Bk.XX:188.
E1:Def.V:45— {NeffEL:L04(04):282, Bk.XIII:113. }
{
Calculus:Fig.
3}
] affections
[ (accidents
)
Hampshire:135—affectus
By mode, I mean the
modifications
("Affectiones")
of
Durant:638 & [6]
substance, or that which exists
in, and is conceived
G-d
through, something other than
itself. {
See Analogy }
G:Shirley's Bk.VII:236-
Mode (modus)—
This common Latin
noun means what it seems to mean—
mode, way, or
manner—and is frequently used by Spinoza
with this unremarkable meaning.
But, deriving from this, there
is also a
more specialized sense. G-D,
who is pure power,
expresses himself in infinite
'modes' or 'ways.' So G-D is prior Spinoza's
Pantheism—G-d
to all his modes,
and a mode is defined as that which is 'in'
something else
and is conceived 'through' something
else. All
existence is summed up in
G-D and his modes {G-d}.
There is
nothing
else.
Shirley's Bk.VII:237-
Affection (affectio) and the verb 'to affect' (afficere)—
.... mode
is defined as the "affections
of substance."
Mode and affection are
similar, but do not cover the same
ground. Mode is restricted
to the "way" in which substance,
or an attribute
of G-D, finds expression, whereas "affection"
is of much wider application,
extending to finite things. ....
{ Hence
I conjoin "affection" and "emotion";
man being a finite thing.
}
]
Bk.VII:2821—emotion
(E3:Def.III:130
= "affectus"; usage by Spinoza
explained. [
Bk.XIV:2:1931.
E3:De.I(8):173.
Hampshire:135
... When Spinoza says
that "G-D is affected by a modification"
Desire
(EI:XXVIII(3):67)
he does not mean that there is something
external to G-D by which G-D is affected,
for there is nothing
Love
external to G-D. ..... he
means quite simply that
G-D
'takes on'—expresses
Himself in—a particular form or state.
{ Calculus:4.4
, E3:GN(2):185,
E3:GN:2n
}
RH—a
particular type or form of something:
Heat is a mode of
motion. Philos. appearance,
form, or disposition taken by a thing,
or by one of its essential properties
or attributes.
[1250-1300; ME mod (e) (< OF)
< L modus measured amount,
limit, manner, kind, tone]
WikipediA,
Morality,
Spinoza's Religion,
Robinson3:189.
Morality is to act so as to enhance G-D—the infinite organism of which you are a part.
RH—enhance 1. to
raise to a higher degree; intensify; magnify. 2. to increase the value,
attractiveness, or quality of; improve.
3. to provide with more complex or sophisticated
features, as a computer program.
A classical myth is the personification
of an abstraction. Abstractions are a society's
'world
views' on Fate, Religion, Soul,
Desire, Justice, Compassion, Sin,
etc.
One day what we think now, will
be considered a myth to future generations just as we
now consider the Roman gods and, perhaps,
the Judaeo-Christain-Islamic God.
Deus.
RH— a traditional or legendary story, esp. one that involves gods and heroes and explains a cultural practice or natural object or phenomenon.
[1820-30; < LL mythos < Gk mythos story, word]
WikipediA—My
Definition.
Mysticism,
Loves G-D, Deus,
Rapture, Organic, Pantheism—G-d,
Awareness, Kabbala,
Bk.III:260—Clay,
Intellectual Love of G-D, PcM,
Schorsch, I:2.7c,
EL:[8]:ix, Martin
Buber, EL:[59]:xxviii,
EL:[60]:xxix,
Cosmic religious feeling—E5:Dijn:258;
E5:Deleuze:130a,
Definition,
Neurons,Soul,
Kabbala—Sefirot,
Mysticism
is that INTERACTING TOTALITY
(a verb, a process, Being)
that is more
than the sum of
the parts of an organism.
It is the interacting, organic totality that is the 'more.' Without the
interaction,
the parts are just door-stops, Examples.
Consciousness
is merely that INTERACTING TOTALITY (a verb, a
process, Being)
that is
more than the sum of the body
controls and thoughts. (If there
are no body
controls
and no thought; the organism is dead and no consciousness.)
Robinson4:156,169, Functionalism—Computer,
Dr. Damasio.
TEI:[10]:5— < E5:Parkinson:285177 >
{G-D
}
But love towards a thing
eternal and infinite
feeds the mind
{mystically}
wholly with joy,
and is itself unmingled with any
Grace
sadness, wherefore it is greatly to
be desired and sought for
with all our strength.
{ E5:XXXII:263,G-D-intoxicatedMan,
Bk.III:261.}
RH— 1. the
beliefs, ideas, or mode of thought of mystics; 2.
the
doctrine of an immediate
spiritual intuition of truths believed
to
Mysticism
transcend ordinary understanding,
or of a direct, intimate union
of the soul with
God through contemplation or spiritual ecstasy;
E5:Wolfson:2:311
3. obscure thought or speculation.
OUP—mystic n. 1.
a person who seeks by contemplation and self-
surrender to obtain
unity or identity with or absorption
into the
Mysticism
Deity or the ultimate reality:
3. or who believes in the spiritual
appre-
hension of truths that are beyond the
understanding.
mystic adj: 4. mysterious and awe-inspiring; 5. spiritually
allegorical
or symbolic: 6. occult, esoteric; 7. of hidden meaning.
[F mystérieux f. mystère f. OF (as mystery
1) 1730-40] Gestalt.
Mysticism is that
INTERACTING TOTALITY that is more than the sum of
its parts.
{Examples of RH(2)
and OUP(1) above
are:
1. Imagine that
you and the room you are sitting in as one
Mysticism
corpuscle.
Feel the organic
interdependence of the Parts.
5P25
2. Imagine
as you drive down a main arterial highway that
you
are part of the
blood traffic—where each
vehicle
has
its assigned task for the
perpetuation of your society.
When
you stop at a red light, feel
you are a corpuscle of
the
blood stopping at a heart
valve. FEEL the organic
Spiritual
interdependence
of the Parts. (the
Worm, EL:L15(32):290)
3. Imagine you
are conducting a large orchestra when that
perfect
chord is hit. Feel the rapture
of love that flows
Intellectual
love of G-D
over
you—the need for every
player, every instrument,
the
audience, the hall itself, the Universe
itself. }
Isaac Bashevis
Singer
ÆFrom Martin Buber's The Life of Dialogue; 1955, 2002 4th Edition; 0415284759; p.31:
The unity which the ecstatic experiences when he has brought all his former multiplicity into oneness is not a relative unity, bounded by the existence of other individuals. It is the absolute, unlimited oneness which includes all others. The only true accompaniment of such experience is silence, for any attempt at communication places the ecstatic back in the world of multiplicity. Yet when the ecstatic returns to the world, he must by his very nature seek to express his experience. The need of the mystic to communicate is not only weakness and stammering; it is also power and melody. The mystic desires to bring the timeless over into time he desires to make the unity without multiplicity into the unity of all multiplicity. This desire brings to mind the great myths of the One which becomes the many because it wishes to know and be known, to love and be loved—the myths of the 'I' that creates a 'thee,' of the Godhead that becomes G-D. Is not the experience of the ecstatic a symbol of the primeval experience of the world spirit?
NAMES, TOPICS, AND HEBREW
WORDS:
Names:
See Bk.XIII:381
for an "Index of Persons" in the Letters.
See Bk.III:283
for an "Index of Names".
See Bk.XVIII:383
for an "Index of Persons".
All Britannica links are from
Encyclopædia Britannica and require
browsers Versions 4.0 or higher.
Britannica has greatly changed; my links to it may not work, sorry. You
can search here.
Alpakhar,
Bomberg, Bruder,
Burgh,
Clark, Coleridge,
Colerus,
Crescas+1+K,
Curley, Charles
Darwin+1+2+3+K,
De Dijn, Rene
Descartes+K,
Albert
Einstein+1+K+3+4+5+6+7+8,+9,
Elwes,
ibn
Ezra+1,
Galileo+W,
Gebhardt,
Gesenius,
J. Goethe+K,
Gusset, Hawking+1, Hegel+K,
Heine+1,
Hillel+1,
Hirsch+1+2,
Thomas
Hobbes+1+2+K, J---vah+1+2,
William James+1+2+3+4,
Jonathan+1,
Josephus+1,Kant+B+1,
Kuklick, Leibniz+B+K,
Lessing+B+1,
Maimonides+1+2,
Marx+B+K,
Massoretes+B+1,
Oldenburgh,
Parkinson,
Pharisees+B+1,
Philo+B+1,
Frederick
Pollock, Rabbi+B+1+2+3,
Rashi+B+1, Sadducees+B+1,
Schorsch+1+2,
Shelley+B+1+2+K,
Shirley,
Singer+B+1,
Socinian+B+1,
Stoics+B+1+2+3,
Strong,
Van
Vloten, Mark
Twain+B+1+2, Wolfson+1+2+3.
Topics—Threads.
See suggestions.
See Bk.XIII:387
for an "Index of Topics" in the Letters.
See Bk.III:284
for an "Index of Subjects".
See Bk.XVIII:386
for an "Index of Topics".
The Internet
Encyclopedia of Philosophy.
Stanford
Encyclopedia of Philosophy. {
An example of the Internet's potential. }
Analogy+Worm+Skin+1+Spiritual,
Better
°PcM+1, Burden
of TTP, Cash
Value,
Cause, Common
Notions+1+2+3,
Conjecture,
Constitution+1,
Consumption
Curve,
Def. of a Created
and Uncreated Things,
Def. of the Emotions, Determinism+1+2+3
Divine
Law,
Dogmas
of Universal
Faith,
Alcoholics
Anonymous's Creed,
Eternity
of the
Mind,
Eternal
Truth, Fences+1,
Fetish, Free
Man,
Games,
Garden
of Eden, G-d
at <
100% °P,
General
Def. Emotions, G-D-intoxicated
Man,
Holidays,
How
to Live,
Human
Fiction
& Universal
Application, Idea
of G-D,
Immortality+1+2+3,
Intellectual
Love of G-D,
Interpreting
Scripture, Judging+1+2+3,
Knowledge,
Leap-of-Faith+1,
Legitimate Desire,
Letter List, Liberty,
Love,
Man's
Highest
Good+1+2,
Mind's
Power over
the Emotions, Martyr
Laws,
Nature
and
Miracles+1,
New
in Spinoza,
New
Wine
in Old
Bottles+1+2,
Noahide
Laws+1,
Pagan,
Parts
and Whole,
Reality
Curve, Religion+1+2+3,
Right
Way of
Living+1+2,
Salvation+W+1,
Scriptural
History, Sexual
Morality,
Doctrine
of No Free-Will,
Spinoza's Insights
Embedded in Hebrew Words,
Spinoza's
Excommunication
Document, Spinoza's
Condemnation
by the State.
Spinoza's
attitude
toward Christianity,
Spinoza
and Christianity,
Spinoza—Faith
versus
Philosophy
(Reason)+1,
Suggestions,
Synthesizing
Spirit and
Materialism, Talmud+1+Torah+1+2+3+4+5+6,
Ten
Commandments; Exo
20:1, Deu 5:5,
True
Good+1+2, True
Idea
and TEI:L64,
True
Religion,
Golden
Rule,
True
Virtue.
What
is New
in Spinoza+JBY
addition, Harbinger+1.
Understanding
human actions.
Finally: every headword
in this Glossary.
Understanding Spinoza Topics: Important, Motive, Analogy.
Conatus, First
Law of Human Nature, Posits, Organic
Interdependence,
G-D
and Nature,
Important, Self-Interest,
Burgh's
Letter—Spinoza's Response,
Religion,
Spinoza's G-D,
Einstein's
G-D, Calculus
and Philosophy
Educators,
Pragmatic
Method,
E5:Note10.
Spinozistic Insights Embedded in Biblical Hebrew Words.
Strong
Numbers, TTP2:VII(77, 78,
80, 81,
83):107,
EL:[37]:xxii, Book VI;
Bk.XIA:6439;
Bk.XIX:10512.
Hebrew
Alphabet
to help study Strong and Gesenius
- Spinoza's Biblical higher
criticism.
Hebrew
roots.
All these words bespeak
an organic interdependence (Being,
inter-relationships) of
parts.
Awe,
3374;
Bless,
1288,1293; Charity,
6666,7355; Commandment,
4687; Desire,
7522, 7519;
Duty,
4687;
Equity,
7355; Fear,
3374; Glory,
3513; G-D,
3068, 0430,
7706, 0136+1;
Happy,
0833, 1525,
8055;
Hear,
8085; Heart,
3820; Holy,
6944; Israel
(3477-9); J---VAH,
3068;
Justice,
6663;
Law,
6664; Love+1,
0157; Loving-Kindness,
2617; Mercy,
7355;
Obedience,
4687; ONE,
0258; Peace
of Mind,
8055, Bk.VI,p.791;
Piety,
4687; Pity,
6666, 7355;
Prayer,
5656, 8467, 8605;
Prophecy,
5012; Righteousness,
6664; Religion,
1847;
Satan,
7854 (adversary);
Schechinah,
7931-7934 (dwell);
SH-DAI,
7706;
Service, 5656;
Sin,
2398, 2399 (miss the
target); Spirit+1,
7307; Verbs;
Word+1+2+3,
1696, 1697;
Worship,
5656.
Suggestion: Analyze
(English,
Hebrew, Greek, and Latin)
Scriptural
words carefully.
Use Books IV, V,
VI, and IX.
Hermeneutika is
powerful—point to
an English word in the King James version and
its Hebrew, Greek
or Latin word
and Strong's
entry are given.
Powerful.
For English,
use [etymological]
and thesaurus entries; I have found
Roots
all of this to trigger many an insight.
WikipediA,
Britannica.
Nature
(Natura), Deus, G-Dand
Nature,
ST:Note 4, Pantheism—G-d,
E4:II:192,
TTP2:VI(19):83.
First law of human nature, EL:[41]:xxiii, EL:[43]:xxiv, EL:L21(73):298.
E1:XXIX(8):68— Bk.XIV:1:254, 3995;Bk.XX:187.
"I wish here
to explain, what we should understand
by
E5:Dijn:257-
8
Nature
viewed as active (natura Naturans {G-D})
{Explained
E1:
Calculus:4.4
XXIX(9)},
and nature viewed as
passive (natura naturata {G-d})."
Calculus:Fig.3
{G-D is not
lowered to Nature, but Nature is raised
to G-D.} Robinson5:40.
{Explained
E1:XXIX(10):69} E1:Endnote
39, Bk.XV:267,;
Bk.III:202
210.
Shirley's Bk.VII:2411 Nature (Natura)— ]Bk.XIII:1943[ {E1:Endnote 29:10, EL:Endnote Dijn:211.}
11.— "This word
is used in two senses, Firstly, it is the
Durant:638
equivalent
of 'essence,' the sort of
thing that a thing is,
and is
frequently coupled with 'essence' (essentia sive—
that is natura).
Secondly, it can mean the whole
of reality,
{
The terms
as in Deus,
sive (that is) Natura'."
One should be aware
G-D
and Nature
of restricting it to the the physical
aspects of reality.
are interchangeable. }
When it is used in the second
sense, I give it a
Capital
letter, although Spinoza—or his printers—were not
always consistent
in this." {EL:L21(73):298}
From Blake
McBride <blake@mcbride.name>
in a comment to spinoza@yahoogroups.com.
I believe natura naturata
and Natura Naturans are one and
1P29:8
the same thing looked
at from two perspectives. Natura
Durant:637
Naturans
sees things from the perspective of eternity, a
Hampshire:147—Nature
single whole unrelated
to time. Natura naturata
refers to
the same thing
looked at as a series of cause and
effect
modes
occurring in time.
Shirley's Bk.XIII:2763—
"According to Spinoza, then, nothing but the whole
of Nature
is free since all individual
modes found in nature are caused
or determined by either nature directly or indirectly
by nature
MarkTwain
through some other mode found there.
{This says that all
modes
are parts of
ONE organism. The cash
value of positing it thus, is that
Calf
one part cannot be abused
without damage to other parts, because
they are all bound-up in an
organic interdependence—slums.}
RH— 4. the universe, with all its phenomena.
[1200-50; ME natur (e) < OF < L natura conditions
of birth, quality,
character, natural order, world = nat (us), ptp. of nasci
to be born
+ -ura - URE, ] ]
to grow [
Objective,
E4:XVII:199, E4:XIX:202,
E1:Shirley:609,
Calculus:6.2b
& c.
{True and
false are objective terms. Good
and bad are subjective
Durant:640,
Ferguson
terms.
A true subjective good (healthy
life-style) increases
Cash Value
Perpetuation
and is objective. A false subjective good (substance
E4:Ap.III:237
abuse)
decreases Perpetuation.}
RH— not influenced by personal feelings or prejudice;
unbiased:
an objective opinion: belonging to
the object of thought rather
than to the thinking subject; impartial,
unprejudiced, detached,
dispassionate, impersonal, unbiased, fair, just, uncolored,
open-
minded. (opposed to subjective;
personal, biased, prejudiced,
warped, unjust.).
OUP— external to the mind; actually existing; real;
dealing with
outward things or exhibiting
facts uncoloured by feelings or
opinions; not subjective.
TEI:[33:3,Note1]:13(formalis)—
(1) In
modern language, "the idea may
become the subject
of another presentation.'' (2)
Objectivus generally corres-
ponds to the modern "subjective,''
formalis to the modern
"objective.''
[Elwes's note]
TEI:Shirley:2617—
Formal and Objective Essence
(essentia formalis), (essentia objectiva)—
"What makes the
terminology confusing is that in current
usage the term
'subjective' is often employed
to express
what Scholastics
meant by 'objective.' But
when ........
(Spinoza) uses the
term "objective" he is talking about a
mental representation
of a thing, the thing as an object
of
Reality
Curve
thought."
{ Full
quote }
WikipediA,
ONE,
G-D,
DEUS, Organic,
Pragmatism, Universal
Doctrine, Duty, Pagan, Popkin:71,
EL:[37]:xxii, E1:XIV.Coroll.:55,
TTP2:VII(50):104, TTP3:XII(61):172,
D2:Dijn:235,
Bk.X:62,
Pantheism—G-d,
Mysticism, Bk.XIB:247142—{
sham },
D1:HirLev19:18.
{Shaw-ma',Strong:8085—hear
intelligently} {exclaim
at moment of death}
HirPent:Deut 6:4—
Hear, O Israel,
G-D our LORD
is G-D the Only ONE.
Importance
of 1D6 = ONE
Compare with 1D6.
The Jewish Religion and Spinoza's
Religion
have the identical Foundation Rock.
Deut 6:4
is equivalent to 1D6;
to say that God is 'ONE'
is really to say that G-D is an infinite inter-
dependent organism—a
paraphrase of 1D6. This first
command-
ment includes all the other
commandments. Elwes
[37].
Cash
Value—an all-inclusive organic
interdependence; you cannot
harm one part without harming the others. Posit. E5:XVI:255.
From Daily
Prayer Book, Dr.
J. H. Hertz. ISBN: 0819700940.
ON THE SHEMA; ITS
MEANING AND HISTORY. Pg. 263.
Hampshire:204
THE MEANING OF THE SHEMA. "Hear, O Israel,
the Lord is our
G-D, the
Lord is ONE." These words enshrine Judaism's greatest
Read "Gifts
of
contribution
to the religious thought of mankind.
They constitute
the
Jews" Pg. 156
the primal confession
of Faith in the religion of
the Synagogue,
declaring that the
Holy G-D worshipped and proclaimed
by Israel
is ONE; and that He
alone is G-D, Who was, is, and ever will be.
That opening sentence of the Shema
rightly occupies the central
place in Jewish {and
all Universal Religions}
religious thought, for every
other Jewish belief turns upon it: all goes back to
it; all flows from it.
The answer to WHY the Highest Good
is to love G-D:
Scripture
and Spinoza declare
that G-D is ONE
to establish that
Spinoza's
Religion
EVERYTHING
is bound into one grand ORGANIC
interdependence;
Posit
from this intuition,
by deduction, "in working clothes",
logically flows
EL:L15(32):290
the Golden Rule
"love your
neighbor..." and enlightened
self-interest.
D1:HirLev 19:18
The Golden
Rule says that you are your brother's
keeper in the
Moral
Agent
sense that your heart
is your lung's keeper, and your lung
is your
Damasio—biological
heart's keeper—the interdependence
of the parts for the life of the
Mark
Twain
organism.
Spinoza's
Religion, Law of Organisms, Enlightenment.
Morality
If declaring "G-D
is ONE", does not trigger
the concept of the
{Organic—
"Organic Interdependence
of Parts" then
"G-D is ONE" is
just
Growth or Death;
words
without meaning. Hebrew
Biblical Mission.
hence, evolution.
}
See Posit,Pragmatic,
Cash Value,
Mysticism, Altruism,
D:2.2, I:2.7c,
E2:IV:85,
TTP2:VII(50):104, TTP3:XII(61):172,
TTP4:XVI(21):202.
When the awareness
of the need of the parts
of an organism
Love/Need
for each other is
realized, °LOVE
for each other
immanently
'I-thee'
follows.
E5:XXXV:264.
ANALOGY:
in the human body all parts are organically interdepen-
Examples—1D6, 2P3,
2P4
dent.
The lung does not do what it does for the heart
altruistically;
heart and lung
but for its own very survival—conatus.
See Charity.
E2:Wolfson:2:8.
You have to give
to get; you have to get to
give—self-interest.
The Law of Organisms
James's Bk.X:63
Pragmatism—Cash
Value—Posit.
1D6=
ONE—Deus
Importance of 1D6 = ONE
"The only way to get forward with our notion
is to treat it
pragmatically. Granting the oneness to exist,
what facts
will be different in consequence?
What will the unity be
Speculation
known as? The world is One - yes, but how one? What
is the practical cash
value of the oneness for us?"
BkX:56
......unity, or one
system of laws holding throughout the
universe,
facilitates explanation, prediction, and control.
{The cash
value of our notion is
that if all things
are in G-D,
everything is
organically
interdependent; you know then,
that you cannot harm one part
without eventually
harming yourself or your progeny.}
WikipediA,
Britannica.
Pagan
, Idolatry , Pantheism—G-d,
Holidays , Religion
, ONE , Organic
{The Pantheon of deified
figures of modern world religions is an
evolution of the
Pantheon of Pagan gods. This
is not pejorative (derogatory)
of either Pantheon. It is the
evolution of the hypothesis
of Religion
Read "Gifts
of
to purer
and purer Monotheism—from the fetish
of a caveman to
the
Jews" Pg. 53ff
an unadulterated
Monotheism.}
RH— 1. one of a people or community observing a polytheistic
religion, as the ancient Romans and Greeks. 2. a person who
is
not a Christian, Jew, or Muslim { sic
}; heathen.
OUP— n. a person not subscribing to any of the main religions
of
the world, esp. formerly regarded by Christians as unenlightened
or heathen.— adj. 1a. of or relating to or associated with
pagans.
irreligious. 2. identifying divinity or spirituality in nature;
pantheistic.
[1325-75; ME < ML, LL paganus worshiper of false gods,
orig.
civilian (i.e., not a soldier of Christ), L: peasant, n.
use of paganus
rural, civilian, der. of pagus village, rural district; see
- AN 1]
°PAIN
, °SORROW, Passive, E3:XI(2):138,
EL:[55]:xxvii,
Ethics: Part III: Def. of the Emotions III: 174—
"Pain [
SADNESS
] is the transition of
a man
from a greater
to a lesser perfection {°P}."
{
Bk.VII:2923,
G:Notes 1 &
2,
Calculus:Fig.2
}
RH— mental or emotional distress; physical or emotional
pain.
suffering, distress, anguish,
agony, torment, torture, ordeal,
Calculus:Fig.1(a)
hell, misery, grief, woe,
heartache, heartbreak, sorrow, sad
ness, affliction, wretchedness, unhappiness.
[1250-1300; punishment, torture, penalty]
Britannica,
WikipediA.
Bk.XVIII:369p24.
E5:Bk.XIB:11041.
Pantheism,
G-D—G-d,
ONE, Pragmatism, Schechinah,
Panentheism, Omnipresent,
Bk.XVIII:32—Bk.XIV:II:39,
Stanford Encyclopedia
of Philosophy, Damasio,
John Toland,
Kabbala, Damasio,
Taking the finite as infinite
is pantheism. Definition
Taking the infinite as finite is idolatry.
Spinozism is pantheism without idolatry.
Spinoza's
pantheism has an "I—thee"
relation with every single thing.
Mysticism
Spinoza's pantheism makes the secular
sacred. Popkin:71,
Popkin:80
Kaufman:23
The supposition of some, that I endeavour to prove in
the
ST:Note 4
Tractatus Theologico-Politicus
the unity ]identification
[ of
Durant:637
G-D and
Nature (meaning by
the latter a certain mass
Durant:64092
or corporeal matter), is wholly erroneous.
{Pantheism is simply
awareness that all parts
are bound
Durant:63985
into the organic interdependence of
an infinite organism—G-D.
Think heart-lung
interaction analogy.}
From Tape 1 - Prop. Hall's Lecture 4 - TB1:51—Pantheism—G-d.
If you begin to look at the world that way, then you can see a piece {a mode} of the divine, if I may put it that way, in an individual person or in a tree or in a sunset or in a set of events in history, all of it working out together. It's a kind of cosmic organism {intellectual love of G-D}, a kind of view {I-thee} in which the holy is an aspector a dimension of everything seen collectively. Notice, however, that whether we're talking dynamism or animism or polytheism or pantheism, at no point are we talking about one single, supreme 'other' that is external {transcendent} to ourselves and distinguishable from ourselves and against whom our lives stand in judgment, and all of that. That's yet to come, and we will be there shortly.
{Pantheism is true,
good, if each thing is looked
upon as a
part of the whole—G-D;
holistically, with none of the faults
of idolatry.
Holism is the theory that whole entities, as fun-
damental components
of reality, have an existence other
than as the mere
sum of their parts.}
Acosism From Encyclopædia Britannica Online Bk.XIV:1:298.
Acosism
has been equated with pantheism,
the belief
that everything
is G-D. Hegel
coined the word to defend
Benedict de Spinoza,
who was accused of atheism for
Durant:637
rejecting the
traditional view of a created
world existing
outside God. Hegel
argued that Spinoza could not be an
Spinoza's
atheist
because pantheists hold that everything
is G-D,
Pantheism—G-d
whereas {some}
atheists exclude the {Jewish-Christian,
Anthropo-
morphic,
Transcendent}
God altogether and make a godless
{connected
or unconnected}
world the sole reality. {Analogy}
{Some atheists ascribe to Spinoza's
Immanent,
Indwelling
G-D and
simply do not use the term
'G-D' because of its
ST:Note 4
organized-religious overtones.}
{In
the Analogy of E1:Note11, it cannot be
said that any one part
of you is
you.} Bk:VII:11—"
no individual mode is
itself a 'God';
nor is the total collection of such individual things
God. G-D is no
mere aggregate that can be divided up or decomposed;
yet, each
Indivisible
mode is a particular
manifestation of G-D." {Nature-
^Conservation of matter} Safir:170
From Audio
Book Club—
Spinoza took the
unorthodox view that G-D, an eternal &
infinite being, is identical with the world.
We are, therefore
ourselves merely parts
of the Deity. Human
fulfillment is
Worm
possible, he believed,
only by rejecting our finite, flawed
selves & identifying with the eternal
within us.
{ In the analogy,
would you say your nail-cuttings are you, or the
manifestation
of you. The cash value
of positing that all are
part
of G-D is that I must show respect to all; must
help him to
Read"The
earn a dignified living; not
out of altruism but out of enlightened
Affluent
Society
self-interest.
}
derogatory
{"Pantheism" is pejorative
if it falls into Idolatry—making
the infinite
finite. Spinoza's Pantheism—G-d
is more in line with my emendation
of
the following RH and OUP entries.}
RH— the doctrine that G-D
is the transcendent {no,
immanent} reality
of which the material world and humanity are only manifestations;
any religious belief or philosophical
doctrine that identifies G-D with
the universe.
{ I prefer defining 'pantheism' as
everything is in
G-D; not god in all,
(panentheism)
because then God could still be
transcendent in part. Britannica
Analogy:
My mind, heart, appendix, etc., are in 'me'. }
OUP— the belief that G-D
is identifiable, {in part} with
the forces
of nature and with natural
substances; worship that admits
or
tolerates { the inclusion of
} all gods
{ into a grand
Monotheism }.
[1725-35; < F panthéisme; pan- + Gk theos god]
WikipediA,
Paradigm,
World View, Duck
or Rabbit, Paradigm
Shifts, Category
Mistake,
JBYnote1—Useless
Correspondence, Prof.
Hall,
Generally, a model, template, or pattern. In recent usage,
the frame of reference or perspective
in which one operates, that determines how things appear and, hence, how
one describes or explains them. (A way of taking experience,
a particular way of spinning,
the world). Spinning: Slang, a particular viewpoint
or bias, esp. in the media; slant: They tried
to put a favorable spin on the news coverage of
the controversial speech.
Weltanschauung:
A world
view or "big picture"; possibly a "paradigm."
{n.
German—a comprehensive conception or image of the universe and of humanity's
relation to it.}
RH— par-a-digm.
1. a set of all the inflected forms
of a word based on a single stem or root,
as boy, boy's, boys, boys '. 2. an
example serving as a model; pattern: a paradigm of virtue.
[1475-85; < LL paradigma <
Gk parádeigma pattern, der. (with -ma n. suffix) of
paradeiknynai to show side by side
= para- PARA -1 + deiknynai to show]
Neff,
Bk.XIV:1:xxiii.
Passive,
Active, E3:11.2n:138,E1:XXIX(10):69,
E3:I:130, E4:II:192,
E4:Ap.II:236, E5:IV(7):249,
EL:[54]:xxvi, Calculus:6.2b
& c.
E3:D.II:129— Bk.XIV:2:1931; Bk.XIX:218b.
"On the other hand, I say that
we are passive as regards
Passions
something when that
something takes place within us, or Subjective,
Objective.
follows from
our nature externally,
we being only the
partial cause {Loss
of PcM}.
{Example—Your TV is broken
E4:XLVII(3):220
and you badly
want it fixed; but you do not know how to
fix it
or where to get it fixed.
See active and E3:GN:2n.}."
{Active—understanding
and having Peace of Mind;
Hampshire:135—affectus
Passive—not understanding
with loss of PcM.}
Spinoza's
Religion
E3:LVII(5):170—
"Again, pleasure
and pain are passive states or passions,
whereby every man's power or endeavour
to persist in his
being is increased or
diminished, helped or hindered."
RH— influenced, acted upon, or affected
by some external force,
cause, or agency (opposed to active);
receiving or characterized
by the reception
of impressions or influences from external
sources; produced or
caused by an external agency; receiving,
enduring, or submitting without resistance;
submissive.
WikipediA,
Britannica
° PEACE-OF-MIND
{°PcM
= Spinoza's acquiescence of spirit
or mind or soul},
EL:[60]:xxix, Bk.XIV:2:311.
RELIGION, TEI:Dijn:14,
MarkTwain's
Man's Sole and Master
Impulse, Buddhism's Nirvana.
Introduction,
Salvation, Blessedness,
Grace,
Serenity;
Religion; I:2.14;
Calculus:2.5;
E4:XXVIII:205;
E4:Ap.XXXII:243;
E5:III:248; E5:XXVII:261;
E5:XXXII:263; E5:XLII(1):270;
E5:XLII(8):270;
TTP1:IV(45):61,
TTP1:XIV(87):66; TEI:[9
& 10]:5; EL:[57]:xxviii.
Peace-of-Mind is linked to Conatus
(the drive to perpetuate oneself)
and Psychology
when that drive is frustrated, men seek a Religion,
i.e. Peace
of Mind.
Spinoza's
Religion
E4:Ap.IV:237— E5:Dijn:26113 on TEI:Dijn:14, E4:Dijn:247, Bk.XIX:130a.
"Thus in life
it is before all things useful
to perfect the
{Mitigation
of Loss of
understanding
or reason,
as far as
we can, and in this
Peace
of mind}
alone man's highest happiness
or blessedness
consists,
Purpose
indeed blessedness is nothing
else but the contentment
The God Gene
of spirit {°PcM},
which arises from the intuitive knowledge
E5:Wolfson:2:311
of G-D:
. ." TL:L34(21):336
{mysticism}
TEI:Dijn:14.
E5:Dijn:257-
8.
EL:Wolfson:2:3084—in
so far as we act.—EL:[60]:xxix.
{°PcM
is being °JOYFUL
(when knowing why
is not necessary);
Calculus:6.2b
or
being °SORROWFUL
(say, losing an arm) but understanding
why,
or by a
leap-of-faith acceptance
saying "the understanding
leap-of-faith
= hypothesizing
resides in the infinite
intellect of G-D"—cause(s)
are knowable.}
Yirmiyahu Yovel
I:2.5c,
Calculus:2.5, E5:II(1):248,
E5:III:248, E5:XVIII.n:256,
LT:L31(18):327,
Determinism,
D:2.18,
HirPs 14:7, Bk.XIV:2:3084,
Help of G-D, Mitigation
of Loss of Peace of mind
Inevitably the limit of knowledge
is reached—at that point
Ignorance
there remains only a leap-of-faith
that the understanding
resides in
the infinite intellect of G-D.
E1:AP(39):78,
D:2.18 HirPs
14:7
Calculus 2:5
{ At the limit of knowledge, "a
leap of faith" is equivalent to saying
"accept the
proposition as a working hypothesis".
A working
hypothesis is
disproved when you find a contradiction. You then
have to fix the working
hypothesis or totally discard it.}
{ If you are upset (lose PcM) by someone's conduct, think of this:
"I
have made a ceaseless effort not to ridicule,
not to bewail, not to scorn human actions, but
Spinoza's Dictum
to understand them."
TP1:(4:2):288.
With understanding comes °PcM. }
{°PcM is
not a permanent state; but it constantly
varies with time
Aesthetics
similar to C:Fig,
2. Note the difference in degrees
in the following
dictionary definitions.}
RH & OUP— {
Positive values } freedom
from anxiety, annoyance,
or other mental disturbance; a
state of tranquillity or serenity;
silence; stillness; harmony,
accord, concord, amity, entente,
agreement, pacification, reconciliation,
calm, ease, repose,
placidity, content, composure. {
Negative values
} disquiet; worry;
anxiety; unrest; turmoil,
agitation, tumult, disorder, chaos.
[1125-75; pacem, acc. of pax; akin to PACT]
Perception,
Conception,
I:2.1, TEI:
[19]:8, Bk.III:50, TEI:
[50ff]:18, E2:XLIX(42):123.
{ The Latin word
that Elwes translates as "conceive"
is often
translated
as "imagine"
by Curley and Shirley.
Imagination,
First
Kind KNOWLEDGE, is
prone to error. E1:Shirley:609}
E2:Def.III:82—
By idea,
I mean the mental conception which is formed
by the
E2:I:83
mind as a thinking thing.
Explanation.— I say conception rather than perception, Mark Twain
because the word perception
seems to imply that the mind is
[
acted on by
]
passive
in respect to the object; whereas conception seems
RH— the act or faculty of apprehending by means of the senses
or the mind; cognition; awareness;
a single unified awareness
derived from sensory processes while
a stimulus is present;
immediate or intuitive
recognition or appreciation, as of moral,
psychological, or
aesthetic qualities; insight;
discernment.
discernment, awareness, sense, faculty, apprehension,
concep-
tion, recognition, cognizance, comprehension,
consciousness,
detection, discrimination, judgment, understanding, grasp.
OUP— Philos. the ability of the
mind to refer sensory informa-
tion to an external object as its cause.
[1350-1400; gathering in]
Neff
Reality Curve
°PERFECTION
(°P) =°REALITY;
includes, COMPLETION,
I:Table 1, I:1.4b,
I:1.5b, D:1.8,
D:1.14, D:1.30,
E4:Prf.(32):190.
LT:L3421:336
Reality (realitas) and Perfection
(perfectio);
Calculus:Fig. 3
Good and Bad; Perfect
and Imperfect: Subjective Terms.
Calculus:6.2b &
c.
TEI:[12]
& [13]:6—Ferguson.
"Pleasure is the transition
of a man from a less to a
Hampshire—purpose
greater perfection {°P}."
Perfection=Completion=Fulfillment
E3:Def. of the Emotions III:174—
"Pain is the transition of
a man from a greater to a less
perfection {°P}."
RH— the quality of being
or becoming perfect; the highest
degree of proficiency, skill,
or excellence, as in an art; the high-
est or most nearly perfect degree of a quality
or trait.
OUP— {for the finite} – the
act or process of making {more} perfect.
{The infinite}– the state
of being perfect; faultlessness,
excellence.
[1175-1225; completion]
°PERPETUATION
(°P), Conatus,
Secret, I:Table
1, ONE, I:1.4ff,
D:1.7ff,
D:1.14, D:1.16,
D:1.24, D:1.32,
E4:XVIII(9):20,
TEI:[109]:40,
Bk XIV:2:178,
Increased or Diminished,
Immortality+1,
Peace-of-Mind, Mark
Twain, Langer.
E3:VI:136—E3:VII:136, E4:XXII(3)c:203.
"Everything, in
so far as it is in itself {no external
object
E3:Wolfson:2:204.
causing deterioration},
endeavours {conatus}
to persist in
Robinson3:15
its own being {by
perpetuating its genes}."
Its
only purpose. Robinson3:59
{°PERPETUATION is
that endeavor that causes a
Damasio
salmon
to go upstream, spawn and die—the PERPETU-
mother-love
ATION of its genes
and thereby, incidentally, the species.}
Dawkins2:Genes
RH— to make perpetual; preserve from extinction or oblivion.
OUP— make perpetual; preserve from oblivion.
[1520-30; uninterrupted]
For study purposes, analyze G-D
into these following properties and phases—
but always remember, G-D is ONE, if you are not to fall into idolatry.
{ by hypothesis,
MOTIVE. (A)-Natura
Naturans and (M)-natura
naturata }:
1. ESSENCE (A). Bk.VII:211, that is Nature (Natura); G:Shirley:2411, E1: DI:45
2. EXISTENCE (A). Bk.VII:211, E5:L29[5](12):318. < Bk.XV:26532—E1:XXXIII(21)n2:72 >
3. °
PERPETUATION
(°P)
(A) or (M). Calculus:Table
1; I:Table 1
° PERFECTION(°P)
(A) or (M). Bk.VII:2718;
E4:Prf:34:190; Calculus:Table
1; I:Table 1
°PERPETUATION
and °PERFECTION
are equivalent terms.
The
degree sign (°) is not consistently
used.
4. ° RATIONAL,Reason (A) or (M).
5. ° REALITY (A) or (M). Bk.VII:2718, that is Nature (Natura); G:Shirley:2411, E2:D.VI:83.
6. SUBSTANCE (A). Bk.VII:223, E1:Def. VI:45, E1:XIII:54, E1:XV(40):58, Term 'G-D'.
8. Attribute (A) EL:[43]: , EL:[46]:
9. Mode
(M) EL:[43];
Calculus:Fig.3
{EL:[43]:
}
{ C:4.4
}
(A) are Attributes
(G-D as SUBSTANCE),
things umperceivable.
Natura
Naturans
Attributes
have no ° sign; they are always 100% °P,
infinite,
eternal,
and axiomatic. Pragmatism,
Quibble,
Sham, Cash
Value,
Duration.
{EL:[43]}
(M) are Modes
(G-d as finite,
things perceivable, see pantheism).
natura
naturata
Modes, when
viewed subjectively {C:1.4,
3.1c, 4.6,
7, & 8}, have a
G-d at <100% °P
°
sign; they are then less than 100% °P, more than
0% °P.
Calclus;Fig.3,
C:3.1,
For the significance of the degree signs (°)
see E5:L29[2](12):317.
Bk.III:250.
see
Pity,
Charity, °LOVE, Compassion, Mercy, Altruism,
Misercordia,
Grace,
Sympathy,
E4:L:22, Justice,
Equity, Organic,
Mark Twain.
{The Hebrew word
which is often mis-translated as pity (com-
passion, love, is
better) is rakh'-am, Strong:7355—to
fondle,
HirPent:Gn
43:14
love, cherish, affection. A
related word is rekh'em, Strong:7358
Roots
—the womb (cherishing the foetus).
Based on this etymology,
'I-thee' Relation
the compassion, forgiveness,
and °LOVE we
should feel for
each
other is like that of a mother
for the issue of her womb,
HirPent:Gn
43:14
perhaps varying in
degree but not in kind;
it is in no way
Dawkins2:Genes
altruistic.
Another related
word is raw-khawm', Strong:7360—a
kind of
vulture (supposed to be tender
toward its young). Imagine what
a psychiatrist could
do with this connection; suffocating love.
E4:XLIV:218}
Bk.XIB:252155.
RH— sympathetic or kindly sorrow
evoked by the suffering, dis-
tress, or misfortune of
another, often leading one to give relief
or aid or to show mercy.
a cause or reason for pity, sorrow, or
regret. to feel pity or compassion
for; be sorry for; commiserate
with.
[1175-1225; ME pite< OF pite,
earlier pitet < L pietatem, acc. of
pietas PIETY]
[1200-50; ME misericorde lit., pity,
an act of clemency < MF < L
misericordia pity = misericord- (s.
of misericors) compassionate
(miseri-, comb. form of miser pitiful,
wretched + cord-, s. of cor
heart) + -ia - Y 3]
°PLEASURE,
°JOY,
Peace-of-Mind, Passive,
E3:XI(2):138,
E4:XLI:217,
E5:Endnote 18:3N,
EL:[55]:xxvii, G:Notes
1 & 2,
E3:De.II:174—EL:Wolfson:2:3084—EL:[60]:xxix.
"Pleasure {
°JOY or °PcM }
is the transition of a man
from a less to
a greater perfection, {°P}."
{G:Notes
1 &2,
Bk.VII:2923.}
E5:XXXIII(4):264—EL:Wolfson:2:3084—EL:[60]:xxix.
If pleasure
consists in the transition to a greater perfection,
assuredly blessedness
must consist in the mind being
endowed with perfection
itself. E5:Deleuze:130a.
{ EL:Endnote
xxix:1, EL:Endnote xxix:1A };
Bk.XIX:130a.
{ Joy (pleasure, happiness)
is mirth, gaiety and elation.
PcM
is serenity, bliss,
]contentment of mind[, [satisfaction of mind]
and (mental
acquiescence); it is possible even with sadness,
when
the cause
is known. E4:ApIV:237,
E5:XXVII(1):261.
}
^
D2:2.18ff.
RH— delight; sensual gratification;
joy, cheer, bliss, elation,
exultation, rapture;
gaiety, mirth, lightheartedness, merriment
Calculus:Fig.1(a)
jubilation, high spirits.
[1325-75; to please]
WikipediA,
Britannica
Bk.XIV:1:xxi.
Pragmatism,
D:2.6c, I:2.5,
Belief, Dogma,
Idea, Posits, Eternal
Truth, Salutary,
C:2.5, TTP1:V(71):77,
TTP3:XIV(39):185, TTP3:XIV(64):188,
James:65, EL:[34]:xxi,
EL:[39]:xxiii, EL:[57]:xxviii,
EL:[64]:xxxi, Quibble,
Sham, Disclaimer, Andy,
Darwin,
The
Pragmatic Method, Scientific
Method, Britannica's
treatment of pragmatism.
TEI:[13:2]:6— {Cash Value, Utilitarianism, Bennett.}
"Thus he is
led to seek for means which will bring him to
this pitch
of perfection, {°P},
and calls everything which
will serve as
such means a true good."
E4:D1
Bk.X:xiii—From
Introduction by Bruce Kuklick to
William James's
"Pragmatism."
"Pragmatism directed
philosophers to look toward conse-
Robinson4:173
quences
when faced with speculative
questions; it argues
Functionalism:27,
28
that every conceptual
disagreement must issue in different
practical effects
if there were genuine
disagreement and
Cash
Value
not just a theoretician's
verbal quibble {speculation,
idle};
..."
{ TTP2:VI(61):89,
TTP2:VII(67):106, EL:[34]:xxi.
}
{ Continue
with Cash Value. }
William James's Bk.X:37—
"The true is the name of
whatever proves itself to be good
Susanne
K. Langer
{abets °P}
in the way of belief,
and good, too, for definite
assignable reasons."
{ TEI:[13:2]:6
}
From
Frank Pajares's Web
Pages "The
Pragmatic Method"
{ Spinoza's "Pragmatic
Method"
—
TEI:[61] }
2.
Consequences of the idea determined:
a. practical
b. ethical/moral
c. intellectual/theoretical
3. Agreement determined through:
a. assimilation {Good
word, because if false, you get a belly-ache.}
b. validation
c. corroboration
d. verification
{The
truth of an hypothesis (or speculation)
is in proportion to
its usefulness
in increasing °P. Pragmatically,
it matters not
that religious
hypotheses violate Logic; what matters
is that the Mark
Twain
hypotheses evoke
°PcM and obedience—justice
and charity;
piety in work-clothes.}
TTP1:Pfc(44):9,
TTP3:XV(53):194, TTP3:XV(62):195,
D:2.8, BkX:56,
D1:HirLev 19:18.
RH— character or conduct that emphasizes
practical results or
concerns rather than theory
or principle; a philosophical move-
ment or system having various
forms, but generally stressing
practical consequences as constituting
the essential criterion
in determining meaning, truth,
or value. Compare INSTRU-
MENTALISM—a variety of
pragmatism maintaining that the
truth of an idea is determined by its
success in the active solution
of a problem and that the value of ideas
is determined by their
function in
human experience. TTP3:XIV(42):186
OUP— a pragmatic attitude or procedure; a philosophy
that eval-
uates assertions solely by their practical
consequences and bear-
ing on human interests.
WikipediA,
Quantum Mechanics,
Einstein.
The fundamental physical theory developed in the 1920s as a replacement for classical mechanics. In quantum mechanics waves {mind} and particles {body} are two aspects of the same underlying entity {substance}. The particle associated with a given wave is its quantum. Also, the states of bound systems like atoms or molecules {modes} occupy only certain distinct energy levels; the energy is said to be quantized.
WikipediA,
Rapture,
Loves G-D, Deus,
Organic, Pantheism—G-d,
Spiritual, Grace.
Einstein's
"cosmic religious feeling" is
a form of Mysticism and the
intellectual love of G-D.
RH— 1. ecstatic joy or delight. 2. Often, <raptures.>
an utterance
Feel
it
or expression of ecstatic delight.
3. the feeling, esp. in religious
ecstasy, of being transported to another place
or sphere of exist-
ence.
OUP—a ecstatic delight, mental transport. (in pl.) great
pleasure Isaac
Bashevis Singer
or enthusiasm or the expression of it.
[1590-1600; RAPT + - URE; cf. ML raptura poaching, rapt]
°RATIONAL,
Reason+1,
°LOVE, Fear, D:1.9a,
D:1.32a, E4:LIX(1):227,
E4:Ap.V:237,
E4:Ap.VIII:238, E4:Ap.IX:238,
E5:IV(7):249, Objective,
Subjective, Good, E1:Shirley:609,
Rationalism,
Holy.
{A man is rational
when he endeavours to perpetuate
himself.
E4:Dijn:247-
8
He may not succeed; but then
it is due to error—Sin.
A man is irrational when he is bent
on suicide; (however
justifiable),
Calc:Note 7.1, Fig.
7, Fig. 8.
in which case, change + to -
in equations of Calculus:Table I. }
{ EL:[54]:xxvi.
}
{An idea
or action is RATIONAL if it increases °P;
irrational
Spinoza's
Religion
if otherwise. I have
linked "reason" (when used in the sense of
Spinozistic
Definitions
"cause") to RATIONAL
to emphasize that all "reasons" should be
carefully analyzed for
RATIONALITY.
E4:XXIV:204—
(guidance),
[conformity],
(dictates).
To act absolutely in obedience
to virtue is in us the
same thing as to act, to live,
or to preserve one's being
(these three terms are identical in meaning)
in accord-
ance with the dictates of
reason on the basis
of seeking
what is useful to one's
self.
{ Conatus,
GN2n, E4:LXVI.Note:232
{As infinite
thing, G-D
is always 100% rational. Finite
things, G-d
Calculus:3.1
less than 100%, are at
times rational
and at times irrational. }
RH— {
Positive values }
based on or agreeable to reason;
sane;
lucid. sound, reasonable, logical;
solid, wise, sage, sagacious;
judicious, advisable, perspicacious; credible,
feasible, plausible,
compos mentis, in one's right mind, lucid, clearheaded, balanced,
normal, sound, responsible: { Negative
values } irrational,
unreason-
able, unsound, insane.
{ Note how
everyday language expresses the
varying intensities with another
word. G:Note 1 }
[1350-1400; reason]
WikipediA,
Britannica,
°REALITY=
°PERFECTION,
Includes, E3:(GN:8
& 9):185, E4:Prf.(32):190.
I define
'real' that which is a product (mode, G-d)
of cause and effect.
From Bk.VII:2718: Reality (realitas) and Perfection (perfectio). Durant:637
In Spinoza, as in Descartes,
there are degrees of reality,
Encyclopædia
Britannica
a concept that Hobbes
found difficult. However, for both
Descartes and Spinoza
being was a question of degree:
one thing
can have more "thinghood"
than another.
Spinoza equates
'perfection' with 'reality';
by 'perfection',
Perfection
he explains, he
means completeness
of being. The moral
Hampshire:70
or aesthetic
connotations of the word 'perfection'
are
secondary.
{Reality
(realitas) and Perfection (perfectio): Objective
Terms: Reality
Curve
Good and Bad; Perfect
and Imperfect: Subjective Terms.}
Calculus:6.2b
& c
RH— Philos. something that exists independently of ideas
concerning it; something that exists
independently of all
other things and from which all other things derive.
WikipediA,
Britannica,
Bk.XIV:1:xxv.
Religion,
Scripture,
Belief, Pragmatic,
Theology, Idolatry,
Quibble,D:2.1,
EL:L21:298,
TTP1:V(55):75, TTP3:XV(62):195,
TTP4:XVII(49):219, Holidays,
EL:[4]:vi, Bk.XXI,
E1:Wolfson:1:158,
216,
Philosophy
of Religion,
Bk.XIA:6967—Skepticism,
G-D, Universal,
Dogma,
Intuition, Philosophy/Religion, Government,
Anti-Semitism,
Psychology,
Mark Twain.
Religion
is an ever-evolving
hypothesis
Scientific
Method
designed to find
PEACE-OF-MIND.
Examples
As long as people have non-understood
wants, they will suffer
loss of peace-of-mind.
That is why religion, government, drugs,
Our
Real Religion
alcohol, opiates, etc. persists throughout
the world.
When momentarily found, it is
called Bliss, Blessedness, Grace,
Spinoza's
Religion
Salvation,
etc.; alas, only momentarily. ^ Bk.XIX:130a—beatitude Hampshire:202
Britannica,
Weber:272.
I read this definition
of religion many years ago but don't remember
Nagel:274
where. I think it was from Kant.
This definition is in no way pejorative
(derogatory)
of religion.
On the contrary,
it is the highest
attainment of the human
Mark Twain
mind—Intuition-Revelation-Insight-Hypothesizing.
I:2.5c, D:2.5d,
D:2.10b,
Psychology
E4:XL:216,
E4:LXXIII:235, Bk.X:56.
Religion
is: enlightened when It helps
others; harmless, when it causes
no harm
to others or oneself;
deranged,when
it harms others or oneself.
Spinoza's hypothesis evolves the Jewish-Christian God—G-D/Nature.
The more reason prevails, the more true the hypothesis.
Righteous
government
(a constitution) is the same—an hypothesis
Spinozistic
Idea
designed to achieve Peace-of-Mind. TTP1:3(37):47,
Din
Dinah Din, or else,
Robinson3:63,
Runes9
If you agree with this definition
(hypothesis) then you can test
each Mark
Twain
religion (or government)
for their efficiency to bring Peace-of-Mind.
{Cash
Value}
E4:XXXVII(8):212— Bk.XV:xx.
(37:8) Again,
whatsoever we desire and
do, whereof we are the
{active}
cause in so far as we
possess the idea of G-D,
or know G-D,
The
God Gene
I set down to Religion
{because it brings Peace
of Mind.}
Holidays
It is said "Religion
is a crutch". There is nothing wrong
with a
crutch
when it helps exist or cure; it is bad only when it causes
D:2.10b
atrophy—stultifies,
literally or figuratively.
The purpose of Religion (Scriptures)
is to bring peace-of-mind—
not teach philosophy, nor to
make men learned. The hypothesis,
TTP1:Divine
Law
that religion
is, need not make sense—only deliver Peace-of-Mind.
As long as man has wants, Religion will persist.
Our
Real Religion,
The word "religion"
as we use it does not exist in Biblical
Hebrew.
Torah
They looked upon
the Bible as
we do our Constitution,
and
Constitution
took it as a given—a
way of life. The Hebrew
Bible was their
Runes
9, Graetz[14]
Constitution
and Legislative
enactments; Post-biblically,
the Din
Medinah Din
Talmud
was, and is, the equivalent of a modern
Law Library.
Hampshire:180[1b]
Would that all cultures
would make it a religious obligation to
Hampshire:204,
209f.
study their constitution. Robinson3:63
When modern
Hebrew had to coin a word for "religion"
they
Important
chose the word (daht)
whose root is "knowledge", Strong:1847
from 3045. EL:[64]:xxxi.
From Max I. Dimont's Jews, God and History; ISBN: 0451628667, Pg. 368.
The founding fathers and the American
people had a steadfast
belief in the {Hebrew
Bible}. The development of constitutional
Runes:9
law through the body
of decisions by the Supreme Court has
acted, in a sense, like a Talmud
in interpreting and clarifying the
Constitution,
and those decisions have come to function
in
{Spinozistic
Idea
American political life
much as: the Talmud has in Jewish life.
Din Medinah
Din}
"Proclaim liberty
throughout the land, unto all its inhabitants,"
from Leviticus
(25:10), is inscribed on the Liberty Bell,
which
rang out its
message at the first reading of the Declaration of
Independence.
WikipediA,
Britannica,
Spinozism, G-D,
G-d, Spinoza's Religion,
Albert
Schweizer:79,
From Max Jammer's Einstein and Religion; 0691006997; 1999; p. 43.
Rejecting the traditional theistic concept of God, Spinoza denied the existence of a cosmic purpose on the grounds that all events in nature occur according to immutable laws of cause and effect. The universe is governed by a mechanical or mathematical order and not according to purposeful or moral intentions. Though he employed the notion of "G-D," Spinoza applied it only to the structure of the impersonal cosmic order and declared that "neither intellect nor will appertain to G-D's nature." He therefore denied the Judeo-Christian conception of a personal God. What the Bible refers to as divine activities are identified {metaphors} by Spinoza with the lawlike course of nature. G-D is the "infinite substance" having the attributes of extension and thought. G-D is devoid of ethical properties, for good and evil are only relative to human desires. What is commonly called "G-D's will" is identical with the laws of nature. People do not act freely in the sense of having alternatives to their actions; their belief in freedom arises only from their ignorance of the causes of the desires that motivate their actions. The ultimate object of religious devotion can only be the perfect harmony of the universe, and human aspirations must accept the inexorable dictates of the deterministic laws that govern life. {End}
The philosophical system of Spinoza,
which defines G-D as a unique substance
possessing infinite
attributes of which we know only
two—mind and body. (The Spinozistic
Ideas I express are just
my opinion; but I have studied Spinoza some sixty-odd
years, still that does not
mean I am always right. I trust any difference we might have will be due
to our having different world
views. Duck
or Rabbit.)
To start to understand Spinozism posit
G-D—The One.
In Spinozism, personal relationship with G-D comes from positing that you are a part (a mode) of an infinite interdependent organism (G-D)—and it invokes the intellectual love of G-D. I, therefore, call Spinozism, Spinozistic Theism. Spinoza's use of religious language.
Bk.XIV:xxv.
Spinoza is a harbinger
of the coming, however long
it may take,
Millennium
of a One-World
Universal
Religion—the One-World
that is
A
conjecture
evolving
as it is being organically
bound together by
Durant:367
electronic
mutations. It is for this reason that I think Spinoza is
the quintessential
Monotheist as is Einstein—they
constantly
sought unification; simplicity.
New
wine in old bottles, Holidays,
Bk.XIA:113,15237,199,
Essay 2.
{The
Washington D.C. Post, June 5, 1998.
Discovery That Neutrinos Have
Mass Could Rewrite Story of Cosmos
"These new results could prove
to be a key to finding the holy
grail of physics,
the unified theory"—the quest for
deep, sim-
plifying principles
that underlie the profusion of objects and
forces in
nature, according to
John G. Learned of the
University of Hawaii, a veteran
neutrino hunter in the Kamiok-
ande group.}
Sir Frederick Pollock's Bk.XII:69
From
Chancellor Schorsch - Spinoza:
RH— a set of beliefs
concerning the cause, nature, and pur-
pose of the universe, esp.
when considered as the creation
of a superhuman agency or agencies, usu. involving devotional
and ritual observances, and often containing
a moral code for
the conduct of human
affairs; something a person believes in
and follows devotedly.
[1150-1200; conscientiousness,
piety = relig (are) to tie, fasten
(re- RE - + ligare to bind, tie; cf.
LIGAMENT) + -io - ION; RELY=
Bk.XXV:[11]
to depend confidently; put trust in]
[1300-50; to bind fast, hold firmly. RE -, LIGAMENT]
{ I conjecture
perhaps "to rebind the parts sundered when cast out
of the Garden
of Eden; to unite the nations into the United States
of the World."
}
OUP— the belief in a superhuman
controlling power, esp. in a
personal God
or gods entitled to obedience and worship; the
expression of this in worship
a particular system of faith
and
worship.
WikipediA,
Righteousness,
Piety, Justice,
Charity,Organic, TTP1:V(18):71,
TTP2:VII(63):105.
{The Hebrew
word for righteousness, justice is
tseh'-dek,
Micah 6:8
Strong:6664—righteous,
integrity, equity, justice, straightness.
The root
of tseh'-dek is tsaw-dak', Strong:6663—upright,
just,
straight, innocent,
true, sincere; (the same root as for charity).
Based on this
etymology, righteousness is the Golden
Rule in
Motive
working clothes—enlightened
self-interest. It is what one lung
does when the other
collapses; it takes over, for its very OWN
Charity
survival; it is not altruism.}
TTP3:XIV(17):183.
RH— characterized by uprightness or morality; morally
right or
justifiable; acting in an upright,
moral way; virtuous.
[bef. 900; earlier rightwos, rightwis (remodeled with
- OUS), ME;
OE rihtwis. See RIGHT, WISE 2]
Right
Way of
Living,
How to live, Man's
highest good, Loves
G-D,
E3:GN:2N, E4:xlvi:220, E4:xlvi(3)n:232, E5:X(3
to19):252.
E5:X(5):252—
The best we can do, therefore, so long as we do not possess
a
perfect knowledge of our emotions, is to frame a system
of right
conduct, or fixed
practical precepts, to commit it to memory, and
to apply it
forthwith to the particular circumstances
which now
and again meet us in life, ....
Bk.III:253.
WikipediA,
Britannica,
Bk.III:14,
191, 214, 253. SCR:Dijn:238-239,
E5:Wolfson:2:3112.
° SALVATION,
°Peace of mind, °Blessedness,
Bliss, Serenity,
Religion,
Immortality+1
All the above mean "to be saved from frustration by the LOVE
of G-D."
TTP3:XV(94):198, E5:XXXVI(3)n:265,
E5:XLII(1):270,
E5:XLII(9):270, Bk.X:56.
E5:XXXVI(3)n:265—EL:wolfson:2:3084—EL:[60]:xxix.
From what has been said we clearly understand,
E5:Dijn:257-
8
wherein our salvation, or blessedness,
or freedom,
Bk.XIV:1:385&6.—Liberty
consists: namely, in the constant and eternal love
Blessedness—E5:Wolfson:2:3113
towards G-D, or in G-D's
love towards men. This
ST:Wolfson:2:3113
love or blessedness
is . . . . TEI:Dijn:14.
SCR:Dijn'sSalvation,
Weber272
E4:Ap.IV:237—EL:Wolfson:2:3084—EL:[60]:xxix.
. . . indeed blessedness
is nothing else but he
contentment of spirit {
°PcM
}, which arises from the
Britannica—Salvation
intuitive
knowledge of G-D: . . . .
E5:Deleuze:130a;Bk.XX:190.
RH— Theol. deliverance from the
power and penalty of sin;
redemption. saving of the
soul from sin, redemption, deliver-
ance; election, grace; means of
surviving, protection, lifeline,
mainstay, rock. { antonyms
} perdition, damnation, condemnation.
[1175-1225; SAVE]
WikipediA,
Britannica,
Scripture, Religion,
Holy, Obedience,
Justice, Neff
EL:L25(78):305,
EL:[65]:xxxi,
TTP1:V(64):76, TTP1:V(71):77,
TTP3:XIII(7):176, TTP3:XIV(8,9,&10):183,
TTP3:XV(94):198, E4:XXXV:209,
TL:L34(21):337,
Neff EL:L74(76):419.
TTP3:XII(61):172—
"For from the
Bible itself we learn,
without the smallest
Torah
difficulty or
ambiguity, that its cardinal
precept is: To
Hampshire:206a—reconcile.
love G-D
above all things, and one's neighbour
as one's
Love is not
altruistic.
self{
the Golden
Rule }.
This cannot be a spurious passage,
Popkin:71
nor due to a hasty and mistaken
scribe, ..."
{ TTP2:VII(50):104
}
Bk.XIB:2554—Bk.XII:433.
{The Sacred
parts of Scripture are the ethical
and moral parts
Interpretation
which demand
obedience to commandments—laws.
Other
Runes
9
parts
may be rejected or interpreted allegorically.
This demand
Yirmiyahu
Yovel
of obedience is the
same as required by any
governmental
or military
law. No explanation of the law or command is given;
nor any philosophy expounded;
just do it—or
else.
Prophets
TTP1:II(106):39,
TTP1:IV(42):61, TTP1:V(9-13):70,
TTP1:V(59):76,
TTP2:VI(88):92,
TTP2:VII(139):113, TTP2:VII(188):118,
TTP4:XVII(49):219.
WikipediA,
Britannica,
Introduction.
Self-interest
, °LOVE, Altruism,
E4:XVIII(15):201, E4:XXXIV:208,
E4:XXXVII(18):213,
E4:LXXIII:235,
E4:Ap.VIII:238, E4:Ap.IX:238,
TEI:[14:3]:6, TTP4:XVI(10):201,
D:1.33b,
EL:[57]:xxviii,
EL:[61]:xxx, this-worldly
blessedness, high-minded,
self-serving, MarkTwain.
{Jungle
self-interest— Survival
is proportional to your power.
Ayn Rand
A strong tribe in a jungle is more
likely to survive than a weak tribe.
Hampshire:179
Survival of the fittest;
there are no laws—power makes right.}
E4:Damasio:170-1
TTP1:III(85):53,
Robinson3:60, Robinson4:173.
But technological advancement and training bring Enlightenment: Nagel:274
4P20
D1:HirLev 19:18
Societal (enlightened)
self-interest— Survival is
proportional to
organic
duty
to playing by the
rules (reason, keeping the beat in an orchestra).
Not true when living
in a part-jungle society.
When a man steals
Dawkins2:Genes
bread and milk to
feed his children, we do
not condemn him.
(When a man is starving, it
is as if he were living in a jungle; where
there are no rules but one—survival,
perpetuation.)
To know the Law
of Organisms is "Enlightenment"and
removes Ayn
Rand; E4:Dijn:251.
the taint of "selfishness".
To get and not give is selfishness,
'I-It' (extinction—the
body eventually dies);
to get and
to give is healthy self-interest, 'I-thee'
(the body lives—Damasio—biological);
to give and not get is altruism,
'I-It' (extinction—the body
eventually dies). Mark
Twain
Rabbi Hillel
(1st Century BCE) taught
"If I am not for myself, who will be; if
Uzgalis -
Hobbes
I am only for myself,
what am I? { Nothing,
like the lung without the heart. }
Analogy:
Unless it is ill, will the heart
do anything to harm
the
lungs? On the
contrary, it will do what it can
to enhance their
performance. Witness
what harm whites have done to blacks—to
the inevitable harm of whites.
Sins of
the fathers; E4:XXXV(8):210,
Organic.
From Uzgalis—Hobbes' Leviathan { Leviathan- Chapter 14, Para. 4.}
Spinoza shares with Hobbes
a powerful negative analysis
Britannica
of popular religion
and the view that individuals operate
Robinson3:60
in their own self-interest.
Spinoza, however, gives this last
Damasio—biological
doctrine a
remarkable twist. He argues that the chief
good
Ferguson
of human life is knowledge
of G-D and that this is open to
Hampshire:179
everyone. To best achieve
this goal we need to
cooperate
Hampshire:202
in various ways. So Hobbes' egoism is transformed
into a
Ayn Rand
doctrine of cooperation and
enlightenment}.
{E4:XVIII(17):202}
Ridley's
Altruism
RH— 1. regard for one's own interest
or advantage, esp. with
disregard for others.
2. personal interest or advantage.
{It is this
everyday definition that gives self-interest its bad name;
because of the connotation
of selfishness.}
WikipediA,
Sexual Morality,
Games, Lust, Self-interest,
E4:Ap.XIX:240,
E4:Ap.XX:240,
EL:[58]:xxviii, EL:[61]:xxx, HirPs 19:10.
{A sex act is sexually moral if
the parties are able to provide for
the possible issue;
able, both financially and psychologically
within the standards of their
society. The motive for the society's
standard is what
best provides for the issue, thus best
perpetuating
that society—virtue.
Society standards:
1. Polyandry - in a marginal-subsistence
society.
Many hunters are needed to support one child.
2. Polygamy - in an unmechanized
agricultural society.
Many workers needed on a farm.
3. Monogamy - in a technologically
advanced society.
One or two workers can support a family.
4. Conjecture:
Short-term, renewable monogamous
contract - In a
computerized
society. With cradle
to the grave
security a
family no longer need depend on a
"breadwinner"; however,
the psychological problem
remains.
Admittedly the above
needs explanation. I hope to do so as
I complete Insight2
and Dialog2.}
RH definition of moral— of, pertaining
to, or concerned with the
principles of right conduct or the
distinction between right and
wrong; {TTP2:Note
8}
[1300-50; ME < L moralis = mor-
(s. of mos) usage, custom +
-alis - AL 1]
WikipediA,
Sin,
Idolatry, Sacred,
Commandment, Duty, I:1.9,
I:10, D:1.10b,
E4:XXXVII(31):214,
TTP1:1(91):22, Bk.XIII:347,
LT:L32(19):331,
Bk.XIV:1:4395—LT:L36(23):347.
EL:L25(78):305—
"But," you urge, "if men sin from the necessity
of their nature,
Mark
Twain
they are therefore excusable."
{
self-interest
}
Ryle:20
{ The Hebrew word
translated as 'sin' is khate, Strong:2399—
LT:L3219:332
a crime, sin, fault.
The root of
khate is khaw-taw', Strong:2398
LT:L3421:342
—to miss, to err from the mark (speaking of an archer),
to sin, to
Popkin:71
stumble. Implied in
this etymology is that there should
be
"no praise—no
blame" ever; crime and scarlet
fever are in the Ripley:309
same category.
The sinner is making an error; because
he, if rational, does want
{The
sins of
to perpetuate himself. Therefore his
error is due to some disability
the fathers
}
or lack of knowledge. This does
not mean that society should not
protect itself as from a crime—by
incarceration, quarantine, or
Letter:3724:[7].
(better) by attempts to remove the
causes (slums, disease, etc.),
or by retraining;
re-programming the data base.
Replace the word
Garbage Data
Base.
'sin' by the word
'error'.
Implied in this etymology is that there
should be "no praise - no blame" ever; ''crime and scarlet fever
are
in the same category''.
Bk.XIV:2:1843&5—impotence;
Bk.XIX:24831.
If a man enters an area where
scarlet fever is rampant and catches it;
society first quarantines
him to protect itself and then seeks to free
the area of scarlet fever and to
cure him so that he can be well.
If a man is brought-up in a slum where crime is rampant
and he turns
to crime; society first incarcerates him to protect itself, and then should
seek to
remove the slum and re-train him so that he can earn a decent
living.}
{ Aristotle
"Nicomachean Ethics"
Book I:
"Shall we not,
like archers who have a mark to aim
at, be more
likely to hit
upon what we should? If so, we must try, in outline
at least, to
determine what it is, . . . " }
E4:XXVIII:205
RH— transgression of
divine law. any act regarded
as such a
transgression, esp.
a willful violation of some religious
or moral
principle. any reprehensible
action; serious fault or offense, to
offend against a principle, standard,
etc.
[bef. 900; (n.) ME; OE syn (n) offense]
WikipediA,
'emotion' versus 'feelings'
°SORROW, I:Table
1, I:Table 2, I:1.6,
I:1.10, D:1.15,
D:1.16, D:1.18,
I:2.5c, E3:XI(2):138.
E3:De.III(1):174—Bk.VII:2923; Bk.XIX:25139, 25343.
"Pain {
°SORROW }
is the transition
of a man from a greater
Calculus
to a less perfection
{ °P
}."
{°SORROW
is a decrease
in °Perpetuation.
Calculus
Its intensity
is proportional
to the decrease.
If
the decrease is negative, it is °Joy.
If
the decrease is zero, it is BOREDOM.
If
the decrease is positive, it is °SORROW.}
This definition holds for a RATIONAL person; not for an irrational person.
RH— { Negative
values of °EMOTION
} distress caused by
loss,
disappointment, etc.; grief; expression of grief: muffled sorrow.
woe; misfortune, loss, trial, trouble,
hardship, affliction, travail,
disaster, catastrophe; bad fortune;
grieve, weep, lament,
despair, mourn. { Note
how everyday language expresses varying intensity
with another word. G:Note
1, I:1.6. }
OUP— mental distress caused by loss or disappointment
etc.;
lamentation.; mourn.
WikipediA,
Soul,
Being, Consciousness,
Mind=Soul,
GDE—passivity
of the soul, 5P27—contentment
of mind,
5P27—{contentment
of soul}, Prf:17—disturbances
of the soul, Britannica, Damasio.
I posit that the Soul (like mysticism)
is not a noun but, merely, the process
(a verb)
of interaction between interdependent
living parts of a living organism.
Being, Definition.
Cash Value:
Your PcM is a function of understanding the
causes of the interactions.
You can then achievePcM
in either sorrow or joy by understanding
the cause(s);or, if beyond your knowledge,
by a leap-of-faith (hypothesis)
attributing the understanding to the infinite intellect of G-D;i.e.
the chain of
natural causes and their
natural effects and the knowledge
that things could not have been different
than they
are. Causes
are in G-D, are knowable,
and will be known some day. Example—losing
an arm.
{Bk.XIV—The love for G-D is thus the sovereign remedy for the ailments of the soul—lack of peace-of-mind.}
WikipediA,
Spectrum, I:1.3b,
I:1.6b, Calculus:Fig.1(a),
C:Fig.1(b), Part
and Whole,
Transition.
E1:XIII:54—
Substance absolutely infinite is indivisible. { E1:XV(40):58}
{ All the individual colors are a part of the color white. Blood.}
RH— an array of entities, as light
waves or particles, ordered
in accordance with the
magnitudes of a common physical
property, as wavelength or mass;
the band or seriesof colors,
together with invisible extensions,
a broad range of varied but
related ideas, objects, etc., that
form a continuous series or
sequence: the spectrum
of political beliefs; { of
°EMOTION}.
OUP— the band of colours, as seen in a rainbow etc., arranged
in a progressive series
according to their refrangibility or wave-
length; the entire range or
a widerange of anything arranged
by degree or quality etc.
[1605-15; appearance, form, to look, regard;
image, apparition
f. spece look]
The philosophical system of Spinoza,
which defines G-D as a unique substance
possessing infinite
attributes of which we know only two—body
and mind.
In Spinozism,
'personal relationship' with
G-D comes from positing that you are
a part (a mode) of
an infinite interdependent organism
(G-D)—and it invokes the intellectual
love
of G-D.
I, therefore, call Spinozism,
Spinozistic Theism.
Spinozism is pantheism without idolatry.
Subjective,
TEI:[33:3,Note1]:12(objectivus),
E4:XVII:199, E4:XIX:202,
Calculus:6.2b & c.
Irrational
False Subjectiveness; liking junk food = Subjectivity.
Rational
True Subjectiveness; liking healthy food = Objectivity.
RH— existing in the
mind; belonging to the thinking subject
rather than to the object of thought . Philos.
relating to or of the
Ferguson
nature of an object as
it is known in the mind as distinct from a
Cash
Value
thing in itself;
relating to properties or specific conditions of the
mind as distinguished from general
or universal experience;
personal, individual, emotional,
partial, partisan, biased, preju-
diced, (opposed to objective;
impersonal; external, concrete,
tangible; impartial, unbiased.)
OUP— Philos. proceeding
from or belonging to the individual
LeDoux
consciousness or perception; imaginary,
partial, or distorted.
[1400-50; late ME: pertaining to a subject {Passive}
of a ruler]
TEI:Shirley:2717—
Formal and Objective Essence
(essentia formalis), (essentia objectiva)—
"What makes the
terminology confusing is that in current
usage the term
'subjective' is often employed
to express
what Scholastics
meant by 'objective.' But
when ........
(Spinoza) uses the
term "objective"
he is talking about a
mental representation
of a thing, the thing as an object
of
thought."
{ See
Full quote }
< TEI:Parkinson:287196
>
Good and bad
(evil), if not true, are subjective terms. E4:Def.I:190,
Ferguson
True and false are objective
terms. Garden of Eden.
E1:Shirley:609
WikipediA,
Bk.VII:22:3,Bk.XIV:1:xiii.
SUBSTANCE
, G–D,
Mode, Bk.X:43, TEI:[33:3]:12,EL:[42]:xxiii,
E1:XIII:54,
E1:XV(40):58,
Sham, Infinite, Neff
- EL:L04(04):282,
Neff - E5:L29(12):318.
E1:Def.III:45—
"By substance,
I mean that which is in itself, and is con-
MOTIVE
ceived
through itself; in other
words, that of which a
conception can be
formed independently of any other
conception." Bk.III:188;Bk.XX:187.
Definition
of an uncreated thing.
by hypothesis
E1:XIII:54—
Bk.VII:223-
Substance (substantia)—
This word must
be divested of many of its common or
scientific connotations. Spinoza's
definition is rooted in
term
'G-D'
a long philosophical
tradition in which the term 'sub-
stance' played a
very important role. For Aristotle the
word had several
connotations, of which one signified
independent and
primary existence: a substance was
the basic
metaphysical individual
by itself (Aristotle,
Categories, 2-5).
Descartes applied this notion of pri-
mary and independent
existence to God
and claimed
that God alone
was the only entity that was really inde-
pendent of everything
else. Nevertheless, he went on to
permit the use of the
term ‘substance' to refer to created
entities as well
(Descartes, Principles
of Philosophy
I: 51-53). It is
the Cartesian
theory that furnishes the
framework within
which Spinoza develops his own
definition and
theory of substance. Spinoza adopts
Descartes' proposal to
apply this term to G-D alone, but
he strictly adheres
to this usage {i.e. G-D alone}.
The
main theme of the
first book of the Ethics is the demon-
stration that
there is one and only one
substance,
G-D-or-Nature
{Deus sive
Natura}.
Spinoza's
Daring.
{Although substance and its identities
are infinite terms, E1:XIII:54;
we can deal with parts
as explained in E1:XV(40):58.}
{Conservation of matter/energy
expresses the eternality of
SUBSTANCE.}
RH— that of which a thing consists; the actual matter
of a thing,
as opposed to the appearance or shadow;
reality; Philos. that
which exists by itself and in which accidents or
attributes inhere.
OUP— a reality; solidity (ghosts have
no substance); the real
meaning or essence of a thing;
Philos. the essential nature
underlying phenomena, which
is subject to changes
and
accidents.
Thing (res),
External, Nature, TEI:[95]:35,
E1:Def.II:45, E1:Def.VII:46,
Reality Curve, Soul.
From Shirley's Bk.VII:249—Thing {Object, Noun, Bk.XII:2191—that which persists in its existence}.
"This is the
regular translation of 'res,' but
the reader
Durant:639
should be warned
that Spinoza gives it a much more
extensive meaning
than is normal in English. He uses
it
I—thee
to cover not only inanimate
objects, but man, G-D,
{ideas,
organisms, the Id,
ego,} and sometimes occurrences."
TTP1:CI(65)
{In short, every attribute and mode of G-D—all parts of G-D.} Pantheism
WikimediA,
Transcendent:
Deus, 1Ax3, 4, 5, 1P3,
Wolfson:1:90-transcendent,
Ghost-in-the-Machine,
"Beyond," in some sense. In religious contexts, often "totally beyond" the level of human access. Other, holy, sacred; on the far side of a great gulf fixed. {Tape 1, Robinson3:63 }
"Transcendent" means about the same thing as having absolutely nothing in common. G-D and G-d (pantheism) are never trancendent because the totality of all things are in G-D. (If X affects Y; then Y affects X; If X cannot affect Y; then Y cannot affect X.) On the religious front, it is clearest in the medieval notion that humans are not in a position to say anything about God because of God's total "otherness." Robinson4:121
RH— 1. going beyond ordinary limits; surpassing; exceeding. 2. superior or supreme. 3. (of the Deity) transcending the universe, time, etc. Compare IMMANENT (of the Deity) indwelling the universe, time, etc.). 4. a. (in Kantian philosophy) transcending experience; not realizable in human experience. b. (in modern realism) referred to, but beyond, direct apprehension; outside consciousness.
Transition,
I:1.6b , I:1.7,
Spectrum , EL:Wolfson:2:3084.
BOREDOM: Instant
of change from °SORROW
to °JOY
or vice versa. Calculus:Fig.
2
INDIFFERENCE: Instant
of change from °HATE
to °LOVE
or vice versa.
RH— movement, passage, or change from one
position, state,
stage, subject, concept,
etc., to another; a period during which
such change takes place.
OUP— a passing or change from
one place, state, condition,
etc., to another.
[1545-55; a going across]
Wikipedia,
°UGLINESS
, Calculus:Fig.1(b),
°BEAUTY,
I:2.5c,
E1:Shirley:609
Ethics: Part 1: Appendix: 52, 53
{°UGLINESS is dysfunction.
Its intensity
is proportional
to the decrease
in
Aesthetics
°PERPETUATION
caused.}
RH— { Positive
values } very
unattractive or displeasing in appear-
Calculus:Fig.1(b)
ance; disagreeable; objectionable; morally
revolting; threaten-
ing trouble or danger; quarrelsome.
homely, unattractive, un-
sightly, unseemly, unbecoming, ill-favored,
repulsive, hideous,
frightful, grotesque, monstrous; evil-looking.
{ Negative
values }
beauty, pretty,
handsome, fair, lovely, comely,
attractive; pleasant, agreeable, personable,
good-natured, lik-
able, friendly; good, nice, sweet,
attractive; promising, auspi-
cious, fortuitous.
{ Note
how everyday language expresses varying intensity
with another word.
G:Note 1 , D:1.26b.
}
[1200-50; ME ugly, fearful, dreadful]
WikipediA,
Understanding,
By Careful Definitions, By
Hypothesizing and Testing, Artistic
Import.
Leap
of Faith, 1Ax4, 4AP.IV,
TEI[16], TEI[92],
Damasio, Weinphal:104,
Robinson3:15.
To understand is to know
the causes of the chain
of natural events; the Way to Wisdom.
To understand is to mitigate
the loss of Peace of Mind.
Velocity,
I:Table 1, I:1.3,
I:1.6.
RH—the time rate of change of position of a body in a specified direction.
OUP—the measure of the rate of movement of an object in a given direction.
{ I use °VELOCITY to serve as an analogy for °EMOTION. I:Table 1 }
WikipediA,
Bk.XIV:1:xxiii, xxiv.
Virtue,
Power
of activity, EL:[61]:xxx, E5:XXV:260,
E5:XLI(1):269.
E4:Def.VIII:191—On Virtue. E5:Dijb:257- 8.
"By virtue (virtus)
and power I mean the same thing; that is
Damasio—biological
(III:vii.),
virtue, in so far as it is referred to man,
is a man's
Man
or G-D
nature or essence,
in so far as it has the power of effecting
what can only
be understood by the laws of that nature
Hampshire:143—virtue
{ to perpetuate
itself }."
Shirley's Bk.VII:2719— Virtue (virtus)
"Spinoza equates this word with "power"
(potentia). This
Hampshire:179
usage is reflected in the phrase
"by virtue of." Spinoza
often uses the term "virtue"
in a moral sense, whereby the
E4:Wolfson:2:221
more we are
endowed with virtue the more we act
accord-
ing to reason, and hence attain
happiness {betterPcM
}."
E5:XLII:270—Virtue (virtus)
Blessedness
is not the reward of virtue, but virtue
itself;
neither do we rejoice therein, because we control
our lusts,
but, contrariwise, because we rejoice therein,
we are able
to control our lusts.
{ EL:[61]:xxx}
RH— conformity of one's
life and conduct to moral and ethical
principles; moral excellence;
rectitude: a particular moral excell-
ence: chastity; virginity:
to lose one's virtue: a good or admir-
able quality or
property: effective force; power or potency:
manly excellence; valor.
[1175-1225; acc. of virtus desirable
male qualities, worth, virtue
= vir man (see VIRILE) + -tus abstract
n. suffix]
WikipediA,
Britannica
, Bk.XIV:1:xvi, xxii, Bk.XIV:2:164
.
Volition,
Free-will, Quibble,
EL:[48]:xxv, EL:[52]:xxvi,
EL:[55]:xxvii.
Neff, EL:L02(02):276,
Determinism,
TL:L22ff(74):299,
E1:XXXII:70, A
watch.
E2:XLIX:120— {E2:Endnote 49:0, L2[9], L2[10], Durant65:177}
RH— the act of
willing, choosing, or resolving; exercise of the
will: She left of her own volition. the power
of willing, choosing,
or deciding; will. a choice
or decision made by the will.
[1605-15; < ML volitio = L vol-, var. s. of velle to
want, wish
(see WILL 1) + -i- formative vowel + -tio - TION]
WikipediA,
World-View,
Paradigm, Prof.
Hall, Bertrand Russell,
JBYnote1—Useless
Correspondence,
Duck
or Rabbit, Theistic
/ Spinozistic-Theistic,
Gestalt,
Mark Twain, Religion,
PcM,
Your world-view is your Religion; and a religion is not easily changed. Stewart:280
Your world-view is your understanding
of the world—understanding
lessens loss of peace of mind.
WikipediA,
Worship/Pray,
Service, Learning,
Pollock, Cash
Value,
Micah 6:8.
Although billions of
people pray to invisible gods, there's no
Conjecture
actual evidence of deities and
devils, heavens and hells, spirits
Religious
Language
and prophecies, etc. They're
just imaginary, as far as a sincere
James
A. Haught
inquirer can tell.
{Their prayer is their peace-of-mind
and one
should not deny a modicum
of comfort to one in a 'foxhole'.
Mark Twain
Not given to abstractions,
the picture they have of the eternal in
their minds is their PcM
and is worth a thousand abstractions.}
Wayne
Ferguson
{The Hebrew word
for worship is av-o-daw
', Strong:5656—
Prof.
Hall:79
work of any kind, ministry, labor, service. The
root of av-o-daw '
is aw-vad ' , Strong: 5647—to
work, labor, serve. Based on
Analogy
this etymology, everyone
doing their duty, practicing enlight-
ened self-interest
is worshipping G-D. Ritual
also has its place
ST:Note 4
in adding pomp,
poetry, song, sociability, and pep-talks.}
Intellectual
love of G-D
Prayer has two
types in Judaism:
1. Tef-il-law', Strong
8605; from paw-lal', Strong 6419,
to judge.
It is a meditation
on objectivity—connection
of cause and effect.
Schorsch
From Hirsch's
commentary on paw-lal' HirPent:
Gen 20:7—
..... means: to take the element of G-D's Truth,
make it penetrate
all phases
and conditions of our being and our life, and thereby
gain
for ourselves
the harmonious even tenor of our whole
existence in G-D
2. Tekh-in-naw', Strong
8467; from khaw-nan', Strong 2603,
to bend, implore, plead;
seek mercy, pity.
It is what is meant by
"There
are no atheists
in fox-holes."
RH—reverent honor and
homage paid to God or a sacred
personage, or to
any object regarded as sacred: formal
or
ceremonious rendering of
such honor and homage, adoring
reverence or regard: to render religious
reverence and homage,
as to a deity.
[bef. 900; (n.) ME wors
(c) hipe, worthssipe, OE worthscipe,
var. o f weorthscipe; see WORTH
{ usefulness
or importance }1,
- SHIP]
New
wine in old bottles—E1:Wolfson:1:158,
1:216,
Bk.XIB:230,
Artscroll:455,
denial of Traditional
idea.
Religion
is an hypothesis
that constantly evolves to
purer and purer
forms of monotheism.
As an example, study how Holiday
themes
Salvation[7]
were re-interpreted
as Paganism evolved
into Judaism,
Christianity,
and, I
conjecture, will in turn (with other
Religions of the world) evolve
Dawkins:192:Genes[4]
into G-D—"The
Universal Religion {E5:Deleuze:130a.}
and the United
States
of the
World."
ES:N8,
Dogmas
of Universal
Faith, Evolution
of the concept of G-D results in
the re-interpretation of Holidays.
See MW
for the Hebrew words.
PAGAN
JUDAISM
CHRISTIANITY
UNIVERSAL
RELIGION
Encyclopædia Britannica Online—
Grace
AND Religion and Roman
Religion.
A CONJECTURE
CELEBRATION OF LIGHT.
LIGHTING THE MENORAH
CHRISTMAS LIGHTS
LIGHTS
NOT LOSING THE SUN FOREVER.
& GIFTS
& GIFTS
& GIFTS
Pagan Winter
Solstice Festival -----> Hanukkah
--------> Christmas------>
Nature Renewal Day
RENEWAL AND PLANTING
FREEDOM
RESURRECTION
FREEDOM FROM TYRANNY
Pagan Spring Festival ---------------->
Passover
----------> Easter----------->
Man Renewal Day
TIME FOR
DESCENT OF THE LAW
DESCENT OF THE
UNITED STATES OF THE WORLD
PHILOSOPHICAL REFLECTION
ON MT. SINAI
HOLYSPIRIT
CONSTITUTION
DAY
Pagan Free Time
Festival ----------------> Shavuoth---------->
Pentecost------->
United Nations Day
Between Planting
and Harvesting?
CELEBRATION
HARVESTING BOOTHS
FEASTING
FEASTING and FORGIVING
Pagan Harvest Festival -------------->
Sukkoth----------->
Thanksgiving------->
Thanksgiving
Britannica—progress
^
I conjecture that
the holidays of the coming Universal
Religion
will be
<
A
conjecture
purged of literal miracles,
imagery, and deified figures; all of which make
fences
(a different 'world view'
for expressing the "Oneness"
of G-D)
Duck
or Rabbit
between neighbors
and peoples of the world.
These fences are
a
Hampshire:209f
violation of the
Third Commandment, Deu.
5:8—"You
shall not make
for yourself a carved image..."
It is the increasingly
electronic-age-caused unification
that will make
these fences
(incompatible protocols) more
and more onerous.
TEI:[14]:6.
Bk.XIA:199; E5:Deleuze:130a.
The United Nations
is today in the analogous position of The
United
Runes:v
States of America at the time of its founding.
The USA had to overcome
the power of
individual states to achieve the power it has
today. Likewise
The United Nations
will likewise overcome the power
of the sovereign
Conclusion
states in
time, because of the inescapable trend of history;
those who
oppose it will become irrelevant.
Shirley's Bk.XI:42
From Introduction by Brad S. Gregory to
"Baruch Spinoza; Tractatus Theologico-Politicus"
The quasi-rationalistic definitions Spinoza sets out in the TTP are Metaphors
related to the final aspect of its character to be mentioned here.
This might be called its linguistic play and manipulation. Spinoza Spinoza's Meaning
employs many of the same terms prevalent in traditional Jewish Spinoza's Religion
and Christian discourse, such as "G--D," "salvation," "faith," term list
"miracles," "divine law," "help of G-D," "election of G-D," etc., but
he twists
them and gives them new, unorthodox
meanings that Re-interpretation
are compatible with his own philosophy.
This is part of his persua-
sive programme, attempting to
bring others around to his own point
{re-interpreted}
of view through the use of familiar
terms. Using the phrase of the late Paradigm
Shifts
philosopher J. L. Austin, one could say that here Spinoza is busy
"doing things with
words": not only using them to try and persuade
{re-interpreting
}
his audience, but also transforming
accepted linguistic conventions.
Yirmiyahu
Yovel
Spinoza's contemporaries were aware of this feature of his works.
John Colerus expresses approval at the way Spinoza begins the
"Ethics", "with some definitions or descriptions of the Deity. Who
would not think at first, considering so fine a beginning, that he is
reading a Christian philosopher?" But on closer examination, "when
we enquire more narrowly into his opinions, we find that the G-D of
Spinoza is a mere phantom" and that Spinoza "takes the liberty to
use the word God, and to take it in a sense unknown to all Chris-
tians." Mention was already made of Philippus van Limborch's
complaint that Spinoza in the TTP uses religious terms in ways that
reveal them to be only words—i.e., Spinoza
was using familiar terms
Use
justified
{re-interpreted
}
in unconventional
ways. Besides the historical
and philological
criticism in the TTP, Spinoza lures and seduces, hoping the reader
will suddenly find himself on the author's side via a bridge of custom-
ary terms used in unfamiliar ways.
[End]
New wine in old bottles.
Cash (effective)
Value.
{
See Pragmatism:
Lecture
II - What Pragmatism Means from Bk.X:28.}
Continued from verbal quibble
{ speculation
}.
William James's Bk.X:xiv. From Introduction by Bruce Kuklick.
James went on to apply the pragmatic
method to the epistemological
Susanne
K. Langer
{how
we know ^ }
problem of truth. He would seek the meaning of
'true' by examining
Robinson4:172
how the idea functioned
in our lives. A belief
was true, he said, Dawkins192:[5]
{a
crutch }
if in the long run it worked for all of
us, and guided us expeditiously
E4:XVIII(7)
{jungle }
through our semihospitable
world. James was anxious to uncover
{enlightenment}
{Efectivo
in Spanish}
Popkin:71
what true beliefs amounted to in human life, what their
"Cash
Value"
Garden
of Eden
was, what consequences they led to. A belief was not a mental
entity which somehow mysteriously corresponded to an external
reality if the belief were true. Beliefs were ways of acting with refer- James's ONE
ence to a precarious environment,
and to say they were true was
Hampshire:202
to say they guided us satisfactorily
in this environment. In this
D2:Pollock:223.
sense the pragmatic theory of truth
applied Darwinian
ideas in philos- Spinoza's
Meaning
ophy; it made survival { °P } the test of intellectual { LOVE } as well as
biological fitness. If what was true
was what worked, then scientific
truths were just those beliefs found to
be workable. And we could
{ Salvation
}
investigate religion's
claim to truth in the same manner. The enduring
quality of religious beliefs throughout recorded history and in all
cultures gave indirect support for the view that such beliefs worked. Hall:3:16
James also argued directly that such beliefs were satisfying—they
enabled us to lead fuller, richer lives and were more
viable than their
{ Consolations
}
alternatives. Religious
beliefs were expedient
in human existence, Mark
Twain
just as scientific beliefs were. { EL:L22(74):299 }
[End]
- Verbal quibble.
William
James's Bk.X:56—Free-will
{
Volition, Bk.XIII[78]:347,
Determinism,
Pragmatism, Quibble,
Cash
Value.}
[1] Free-will
thus has no meaning unless it be a doctrine
of relief.
As such, it takes its place
with other religious doctrines. Between
them, they build up the old wastes and repair
the former desolations.
Our spirit, shut within this courtyard
of sense-experience, is always
saying to the intellect upon the tower: "Watchman,
tell us of the night,
if it aught of promise bear,"
and the intellect gives it then these terms
of promise.
[2]
Other than this
practical significance, the words
God, free-will,
design, etc., have none. Yet
dark tho they be in themselves, or
intellectualistically taken,
when we bear them into life's
thicket
with us the darkness there grows light about us.
If you stop, in deal-
ing with such
words, with their definition,
thinking that to be
an
intellectual finality, where are you?
Stupidly staring at a pretentious
sham! "Deus
est Ens, a se, extra et supra omne genus, necessarium,
unum, infinite perfectum,
simplex, immutabile, immensum, aeternum,
Susanne K. Langer
intelligens,"
etc.,—wherein is such a definition
really instructive?
It means less than
nothing, in its pompous
robe of adjectives.
Pragmatism alone
can read a positive meaning into it, and for that
she turns her back upon
the intellectualist point of view altogether.
"God's
in his heaven; all's right with the
world!"—That's the real
heart of our theology,
and for that you need no rationalist
definitions.
{ ^ Peace
of-Mind }
{Disclaimer:
I believe speculations,
metaphysics, should
be
Hampshire
pursued;
although at times covertly;
at times overtly.
Religious
hypotheses and knowledge
constantly evolve to
elegant
simplicity. It is
just that my major
interest is studying
the implications
of Spinoza's thought. Both the steam theoreti-
cian and the steam engine designer
are necessary.}
EL:[34]:xxi—Big
Bang.
Andy
[3]
Why shouldn't all of us, rationalists as well as pragmatists, confess
this? Pragmatism,
so far from keeping her eyes bent on the immedi-
Susanne
K. Langer
ate practical foreground, as she
is accused of doing, dwells just as
much upon the world's remotest perspectives.
[4]
See then how all these ultimate questions turn, as it were,
upon
their hinges; and from looking backwards
upon principles, upon an
erkenntnisstheoretische Ich, a
God, a Kausalitatsprinzip, a Design,
a Free-will,
taken in themselves, as something august and exalted
above facts,—see,
I say, how pragmatism shifts the emphasis and
looks forward into facts themselves.
The really vital question for us
all is, What is this world going to be?
What is life eventually to make
of itself? The centre of gravity
of philosophy must therefore alter its
place. The earth of
things, long thrown into shadow by the glories
of the upper ether, must resume its rights.
To shift the emphasis in
this way means that philosophic
questions will fall to be treated by
minds of a less abstractionist
type than heretofore, minds more
scientific
and individualistic in their tone yet
not irreligious either.
Philosophy/Religion
It will be an alteration
in "the seat of authority" that
reminds one
almost of the
Protestant reformation. And as, to
papal minds,
Protestantism
has often seemed a mere mess of anarchy and confu-
sion, such, no doubt, will pragmatism
often seem to ultra-rationalist
minds in philosophy.
It will seem so much sheer trash, philosophi-
cally. But life wags
on, all the same, and compasses its ends, in
Protestant countries. I venture to
think that philosophic Protestantism
will compass a not dissimilar prosperity.
[End
- James's pragmatism]
{Quibble,
Speculation (conjectural consideration of a matter).
Transient
or Immanent G-D, Freewill
or No Freewill speculations are all
hypothetical, Pragmatism,
Dogma, I:2.8c
, I:2.13b , Cash Value
, Sham
A contradiction with the speculation (hypothesis) of a transcendent G-D:
By positing that
the universe is not part of G-D: G-D's
attributes
are limited; thus His
Power is limited—a contradiction. You can get
around it by
saying He manipulates the
attributes like puppets.
Thus either speculation
gives the same practical results. Spinoza
and Einstein
prefer the immanent G-D because
a transcendent G-D,
among other things,
makes for miracles;
an immanent G-D does not.
A speculation
(hypothesis) that there is freewill
is more pedagogical
in
that it establishes a logical
basis for:
1. teaching to make more effort.
2. praise or blame (award or punishment}
Rabbinic
Judaism very rarely, if ever, concerns itself with speculative
Talmud
and Miracles
matters. It concerns itself with
the study of the law and its observance;
Runes9
much as a lawyer
does today. It posits
G-D as an axiom
and goes
on from there
with no further metaphysical
discussion. A citizen accepts
Spinozistic
Idea
his constitution
as an axiom and goes on from there.
E-mail for clarification request,
disagreement, or suggestion.
SPINOZISTIC GLOSSARY
and INDEX
Revised: September 20, 2006
HOME PAGE
"A Dedication to Spinoza's
Insights"